Why Do People Think RWBY Isn't an Anime?

The debate over whether RWBY should be classified as an anime has been ongoing for several years, engaging a vibrant fan community and sparking varied opinions. This article explores the key factors influencing this dialogue, shedding light on the complex intersection of production, art style, cultural context, and personal interpretation.

Production and Origin

The primary reason many people argue against categorizing RWBY as an anime lies in its origin and production. RWBY is produced by Rooster Teeth, an American company headquartered in Texas. This immediate association with an American production studio often leads to the conclusion that the series should be classified as an American animated series rather than anime, which is typically recognized as animation produced in Japan.

Art Style and Aesthetics

While RWBY features a distinct art style heavily influenced by anime aesthetics, some viewers contend that it does not fully embody the traditional characteristics of anime. Anime is renowned for its specific animation techniques, such as fluid movements, detailed facial expressions, and a unique character design. Although RWBY shares similar visual elements, it may lack the intricate nuances that define traditional Japanese animation.

Cultural Context and Themes

The cultural context and narrative style of RWBY also contribute to the debate. Anime is often defined by more than just its visual style; it encompasses themes, storytelling methods, and cultural context that resonate distinctly with Japanese audiences. RWBY’s American cultural influences and narrative style differ significantly from those commonly found in Japanese anime. This divergence can lead to the perception that RWBY is not a true representation of the anime genre.

Community and Marketing

The anime community has sometimes held rigid definitions of what qualifies as anime. This can result in pushback against works that do not originate from Japan. The push and pull within the fan community highlight how personal interpretation and cultural expectations play a critical role in determining the classification of RWBY.

Controversial Points and Definitions

Several points of contention further emphasize the debate. RWBY's origin in Texas, the Western cultural context of its creator Monty Oum (an Asian American), and the production and distribution by a predominantly white team all contribute to the perception that RWBY is not a true anime. Additionally, RWBY originated as a web series that was adapted into an anime later, with the anime series “RWBY: Icequeendom” being produced in Japan, adding to the confusion.

While RWBY does have some Japanese elements, such as Asian characters and influences, the overall production and broader context place it in a different category. The term "anime" in Japan refers to all animation, but outside of Japan, it specifically denotes animation produced in Japan.

Conclusion

Ultimately, the classification of RWBY as anime or not remains subjective and depends on individual perspectives on cultural origins, artistic style, and narrative context. The debate demonstrates the complexity of genre classification and the significance of both production origin and cultural reception in defining such classifications.