Why Disney Chose Halle Bailey to Play Ariel: A Comprehensive Analysis

Disney's decision to cast Halle Bailey as Ariel in the live-action adaptation of Disney's The Little Mermaid has sparked discussions and debates. From her vocal talents to representation and fresh interpretation, Bailey's casting has significant implications. This article explores these aspects in greater detail.

Presentation of Vocal Talent

Halle Bailey rose to prominence with her powerful and versatile singing voice, a critical factor in her casting as Ariel. Her performance in the musical duo Chloe x Halle further solidified her ability to captivate audiences with her melodic prowess. As Ariel, a character renowned for her iconic songs, Bailey's vocal talent was an essential component that made her the perfect choice for the role.

Acting Skills

While Bailey's singing abilities were undoubtedly the primary reason for her casting, her demonstrated acting skills in various projects, including the series The Killing Season, added depth to her qualifications. Her ability to convey emotions and bring characters to life through performance set her apart as a multifaceted artist capable of excelling in both singing and acting.

Representation and Inclusivity

Casting Halle Bailey, a Black actress, was part of Disney's broader effort to promote diversity and inclusivity in their films. This decision aimed to re-imagin[e] classic characters to better reflect contemporary audiences and inspire young viewers of all backgrounds. Representing Ariel, a character who has been portrayed predominantly by white actresses, with a Black actress challenged stereotypes and offered new possibilities for representation.

Fresh Interpretation and Storytelling

Disney sought to bring a new interpretation to the beloved character of Ariel. Bailey's unique qualities were seen as a way to refresh the story while honoring its roots. Her age and appearance, though sometimes criticized, were carefully considered to fit the narrative's needs. Bailey's young age (16 at the time of filming) was designed to portray a sense of youthful innocence and naivety that resonates with the character.

Controversies and Critiques

While Bailey's casting was praised for its inclusivity, some critics have raised concerns about her appearance. It was suggested that Ariel should look more like a mermaid with scales in the same color as her tail and fewer revealing elements. The rationale was that merpeople are not descended from Europeans, and thus, their representation should be more diverse. In the remake, Ariel's older sisters were given ethnicities that reflected the seven seas, making a case for a more inclusive and representative design.

Casting Based Solely on Vocal Abilities

It is important to note that Halle Bailey was cast based solely on her singing abilities. There were no racial or other political considerations involved in the casting process. Even though some critics find fault with her age and appearance, Bailey's vocal talent was the primary reason for her selection. Her rendition of 'Part of Your World' and other iconic songs showcased her ability to bring Ariel's voice to life in a powerful and authentic way.

Conclusion

The casting of Halle Bailey as Ariel represents a significant move towards inclusivity in Disney's storytelling. While her appearance and acting skills continue to be subjects of discussion, her vocal abilities alone make her an excellent choice for the role. As discussions around representation and diversity continue, it remains to be seen how this casting decision will influence future adaptations and portrayals in Disney's repertoire.