Why Didn’t Sirius Give Harry a Straight Answer in OotP?

Introduction

In the Harry Potter series, particularly in Order of the Phoenix (OotP), Sirius Black's decision not to give Harry a straight answer regarding living with him after Harry’s expulsion is a complex and nuanced element of their relationship. This essay delves into the reasons behind Sirius's lack of a definitive answer and explores the impact it has on their bond.

Why Sirius Couldn't Give a Straight Answer

Sirius Black, despite his love and affection for Harry, was hesitant to provide Harry with a definitive answer about living with him, especially after Harry was expelled from Hogwarts. This hesitation stems from a combination of factors, including legal and personal circumstances.

Legal Circumstances

During Harry's fourth year, Sirius was a wanted criminal, evading the authorities and living a life of uncertainty. Throughout the book, Sirius intermittently visited Harry at Grimmauld Place, indicating his availability to support Harry when needed. However, the legal situation was not favorable for Harry at the time. Harry, aware that the protective enchantments on his home would become obsolete after his return, was forced to return to the Dursleys, where his protective spell would remain active.

Dumbledore's Intervention

It was Albus Dumbledore who played a crucial role in ensuring that Harry was not expelled. Dumbledore understood the complex factors at play and intervened to protect Harry from any legal repercussions, even if he had not yet explained the reasons to Harry. Sirius, with his history as a hunted criminal, could not risk any further legal complications, as they would only intensify his precarious situation.

Simmering Longings and Realities

Despite the legal uncertainties, Sirius longed for the opportunity to have Harry live with him. The prospect of being an outcast together, as both Harry and Sirius had been in their own ways, offered a sense of unity and solace. Moreover, Harry's expulsion would have necessitated a home for him, thus potentially providing Sirius with an opportunity to welcome Harry into his life.

Deeper Magic and Unpredictability

Sirius was aware that the legal situation was incredibly complex, and it would take something extremely unusual or catastrophic for Harry to be expelled or found guilty. As such, while he longed for the possibility, he also understood that it was highly improbable. His hesitation was born from a deep-seated realization that, legally, Harry would have to return to Hogwarts for the protective enchantments to continue.

Personal Revelation

Despite this, Sirius would have welcomed Harry with open arms if the circumstances had allowed it. Hermione’s observation highlights that Sirius was actually hoping for Harry to be expelled. This longing for an outcast companion resonated with his own past, and the idea of uniting in their shared experience was emotionally compelling.

Conclusion

In summary, Sirius Black's inability to give Harry a straight answer about living with him after his expulsion in Order of the Phoenix was a result of legal uncertainties and a deep-seated hope for a different reality. While the situation was challenging, Sirius's unwavering love for Harry and his readiness to embrace him if given the chance attest to his character's complexity and depth.