Who Should Have Voiced Harley Quinn in the Movie?

When it comes to discussing the voice acting that brings Harley Quinn to life, opinions can range widely. But one thing is agreed upon: Tara Strong's portrayal is a standout. However, it's intriguing to explore the discussions around other potential candidates, especially those who thought other actresses, like Hynden Walch and Melissa Rauch, would have been closer to the original voice of Harley Quinn, Sorkin's voice.

Tara Strong: The Gold Standard

For many fans of the DC universe and the Harley Quinn animated series, Tara Strong is the voice of choice when it comes to Harley Quinn. The reasons for this are numerous, but one major factor is her consistency and range in voicing the character across various projects. Her performance in Archam City, Archam Knight, and other animated DC productions has earned her widespread acclaim. Strong brings a level of depth and authenticity to Harley that sets her apart from her contemporaries.

Why Tara Strong?

Strong's portrayal of Harley Quinn is so beloved because it captures the essence of the character in a way that aligns with the audience's expectations. Her voice conveys the right mix of manic energy, unpredictability, and a hint of vulnerability that makes Harley so memorable. Fans who feel that Hynden Walch and Melissa Rauch deviate from the essence of Sorkin's performance often cite Strong's ability to balance these traits perfectly.

Harley Quinn in the Movie: A Voice Debate

When it comes to voicing Harley Quinn in the live-action film, the debate is still ongoing. Margot Robbie, who took on the role, has received both praise and criticism. Some fans appreciate her performance and see potential for growth, while others prefer to stick with the animated series. For instance, Hynden Walch and Melissa Rauch, though less commonly remembered, had their nuances that some felt brought them closer to Sorkin's original performance.

Hynden Walch and Melissa Rauch: An Analysis

Hynden Walch was notable for her role in The Batman animated series, particularly in movies like Arsenal of Evil and Hush. Her voice offered a different take on Harley, one that fans often feel was more reminiscent of Sorkin's, especially in terms of the character's wit and amusing quips. Similarly, Melissa Rauch, known for her work in the Batman animated series, had her own unique interpretation of Harley that, while well-meaning, didn't align as closely with the original voice.

Custodianship of the Character

Assuming we see another Harley Quinn movie, it's crucial to get the voice right. The character's voice is a critical component of her personality and the emotional landscape of the narrative. If Margot Robbie was the voice of Harley in the movie, it's essential that she embodies the right essence to carry the character forward. In line with Strong's example, the character needs a voice that can encapsulate the humor, intensity, and unpredictable nature that make Harley such a beloved figure in the DC universe.

Conclusion: A Blend of Authenticity and Evolution

In summary, when it comes to bringing Harley Quinn to life, the choice of voice is paramount. Tara Strong stands out as the gold standard, not only for her consistent excellence but also for her ability to evolve the character authentically over time. While other actresses like Hynden Walch and Melissa Rauch also have their merits, the character of Harley Quinn thrives under the guidance of Strong's voice. As discussions continue, the emphasis remains on finding the perfect harmony between the animated series and the live-action film, where the voice of Harley truly encapsulates the magic of the character.

Keywords: Tara Strong, Harley Quinn, Voice Acting