What If Severus Snape Survived: Would He Still Be Headmaster of Hogwarts?

One of the most intriguing questions that arise after reading the Harry Potter series is what would have happened if Severus Snape had survived the events portrayed in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. In this scenario, it is highly likely that Snape would have retained his position as Headmaster of Hogwarts for a prolonged period, given his complex history and the unique circumstances of his appointment.

The Context of Snape's Tenure

During his tenure as Headmaster, Snape's leadership was marked by controversy and conflict. His past allegiance to Voldemort and the controversial circumstances of his appointment to the position raised skepticism and suspicion among the Hogwarts community and the wider wizarding world. If Snape had survived, these factors would have likely influenced the level of acceptance he would receive.

Post-War Reflection and Redemption

Post-war, Snape might have been seen as a complex figure. As a former Death Eater, he was also a hero who played a crucial role in the fight against Voldemort. His survival could have led to a period of reflection and potential redemption. In this period, Snape might have sought to reform the school and address the issues stemming from the war. However, the acceptance of Snape as Headmaster would largely depend on the attitudes of the new Ministry of Magic and the Hogwarts community, including students and parents. Given his past, many might have been wary of him, while others might have recognized his contributions.

A Slytherin with Ambitious Goals

While Snape's survival might have led to a period of reflection, it is also important to consider his character traits, especially as a Slytherin. Having attended one of the four houses at Hogwarts, Snape was driven by ambition, cunning, and a desire for public acknowledgment. Throughout the series, we see instances where Snape sought validation, such as his demand for mentions in the Order of Merlin and his enjoyment of flattery from Draco. These traits suggest that Snape might not have been content with merely surviving, but would have strived for greater recognition and accomplishment.

The Potential of a Post-War Headmaster

Clearing His Name and Proving Himself: In a post-war environment, if Snape managed to clear his name and prove how much he had done for the wizarding world, as Dumbledore instructed, it is highly probable that he would want to be the Headmaster. His survival and active support during the war might have convinced the Ministry and the community of his worthiness.

Defining Slytherin's Place: With the pressure of war lifted, Snape would have decades to re-evaluate and redefine Slytherin's place among the houses. He could have redefined the House values to promote recklessness rather than just malice, potentially giving them a unique heritage. Additionally, he could have revisited and updated the school's textbooks, which were often outdated, to better serve the current educational needs. His work ethic and potential connections with figures like Nicholas Flamel could have allowed him to contribute significantly to the field of potions and DADA.

In conclusion, if Severus Snape had survived, his journey as the Headmaster of Hogwarts would have been marked by both challenges and opportunities. It would have been a period of reflection, potential redemption, and the possibility of reshaping the school in a way that honored his legacy and the lessons learned in the war.