What If Robb Stark Had Kept Winterfell and Tarnished Walder Frey's Loyalty?

Game of Thrones, the saga of political intrigue, warfare, and shifting alliances, captivates audiences with its rich mythology and complex characters. One fascinating 'what if' scenario involves Robb Stark garnering a different outcome at the Battle of Blackwater. This article explores the intricate consequences of a victorious Robb Stark and the impact it would have on the loyalty of Walder Frey and the fate of the Stark family.

Blackwater and the Lingering Shadow of Walder Frey

After the Battle of Blackwater, it becomes clear that Walder Frey would perceive Robb Stark as a losing faction. The Freys, who are known for their cunning and opportunistic tendencies, would quickly see the wisdom in aligning themselves with the Lannisters. Walder Frey had already established a strategic partnership with the Lannisters, allowing his sons to thrive at Casterly Rock. However, his betrayal of the Starks at the crucial moment of the Red Wedding had come at a heavy cost.

Analysis of Walder Frey's Position

Walder Frey found himself in a precarious situation well before Tywin Lannister commanded the Westerlands. In the past, Lord Walder Frey and Lord Tytos Lannister agreed to a marriage between Genna Lannister and Emmon Frey. At the time, the Lannisters were still influential and powerful, with Genna as a significant asset. This strategic alliance seemed promising, but it quickly soured. Tywin's opposition and the subsequent Reyne-Tarbeck rebellion underscored the folly of the arrangement.

Consequences of Walder Frey's Treachery

Walder Frey's decision to support the Starks at the Battle of Blackwater ultimately led to a series of catastrophic events. The death or capture of key figures such as Jamie Lannister and Edmure Tully would have severe ramifications. Without these leaders, the Lannister forces would have struggled to secure the Westerlands. Moreover, the Lannisters would need to act swiftly to consolidate their hold on the region.

Cunning of Lord Bolton

Another scenario worth exploring is Lord Bolton and his strategic moves. If Robb Stark had not lost Winterfell, the Bolton family might have found an opportunity to consolidate power in the North. Bolton's cunning and loyalty to the Starks would have made him a potential savior for Robb. However, with Walder Frey's betrayal still fresh in their minds, Bolton's efforts might face resistance or mistrust.

Strategic Alliances and Loyalties

The crux of the argument lies in the delicate balance of alliances and loyalty. For Robb Stark to navigate these treacherous waters effectively, he would need to establish strong and reliable allies. However, the Freys, driven by their self-interest, would be incredibly difficult to win back. Robb's best strategy might be to seek external support from powerful houses, such as the Tyrells or the Martells, to counter the looming threat of the Lannisters.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the scenario where Robb Stark retains control of Winterfell and avoids the Red Wedding would have profound consequences. Walder Frey's loyalty would not necessarily return, and he would likely remain a hawkish ally of the Lannisters. Understanding these complexities provides insight into the intricate political landscape of Westeros and the critical role of strategic alliances in determining the fate of the various houses.