Understanding the Puzzling Departure of the Darkhold in Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. Season 4

Season 4 of the Marvel series Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. introduced a significant development involving the Darkhold and Johnny Blaze, which has left many fans puzzled. Specifically, why did Johnny Blaze, a pivotal character, leave the Darkhold in a seemingly abandoned basement out of off-screen episodes?

It's important to remember that conflating the comic books with the on-screen universe can sometimes lead to confusion. Each medium operates within its own narrative framework, and sometimes the differences are crucial for the story's progression.

MacGuffin or Central Plot Element?

Within the context of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., the Darkhold's presence in Blaze's abandoned basement can be seen as a MacGuffin. A MacGuffin is a term used in screenwriting for a plot device that drives the plot but is not particularly important in and of itself. It's a means to an end, something that needs to be obtained to move the story forward. In this case, Blaze leaving the Darkhold creates a catalyst for further events, likely leading to more significant plot developments.

The Conundrum of Zarathos and Robbie's Deal

Another layer of complexity is introduced by the relationship between Zarathos and Robbie Baldwin. In the show, Robbie says, “I made a deal with the devil.” This phrase is significant as it raises questions about who exactly Robbie made that deal with and why.

Firstly, it's crucial to note that Robbie's statement doesn’t definitively identify who the "devil" is. The term "devil" can be symbolic or literal, and given the context of the show, it could refer to various entities. For instance, Robbie might have made a deal with a Spirit of Vengeance (as depicted in the comic books) or with Mephisto, the king of Hell. Alternatively, "the devil" could be used as a figure of speech, meaning he made a difficult but significant decision.

Secondly, there’s an intriguing theory that Zarathos, who controls the Darkhold, might not be the entity telling Robbie the truth. The show has a history of playing with the identities and motivations of key characters, often revealing more about them as the series progresses.

The Role of Mephisto and Other Riders

There's also the possibility that Mephisto is involved. He is a key figure in the Marvel universe, having interactions with various riders, including Blaze. Additionally, the series introduces other Ghost Rider characters, such as the ninth-century Rider, further complicating the narrative. Some theories suggest that the ninth-century Rider may be the true Zarathos, with Mephisto using his power to deceive Robbie and manipulate events.

Placing the Mystery in Context

To fully understand the significance of Johnny Blaze leaving the Darkhold and the role of Zarathos and Robbie's deal, it's essential to consider the broader narrative of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.. The show often presents multiple layers of truth, with characters having hidden agendas, and the Darkhold being a central plot device in many episodes.

Johnny Blaze's departure and Robbie's deal are part of a larger strategy to control the power of the Darkhold and maintain order within the universe. These actions set up many of the series' subsequent plot points, driving the narrative towards future revelations and conflicts.

While theories and interpretations are vast, the key is to keep an open mind, watch the narrative closely, and embrace the complexity of the Marvel canon. This approach will not only enhance your viewing experience but also deepen your understanding of the intricate storytelling within Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D..