Why was Transformers: Beast Machines so bad?

Transformers: Beast Machines is often criticized for its poor execution and divergence from its predecessor, Beast Wars. However, many fans argue that it's not as terrible as rumored, presenting its unique merits despite its flaws.

Departure from the Original Formula

The series significantly diverged from the beloved Beast Wars. The critical difference began from the outset, as the creators of Beast Machines were explicitly told not to watch Beast Wars. This instruction aimed to ensure a completely original storyline, ostensibly to boost toy sales. Critics argue that, paradoxically, this directive led to a show that was too different, failing to capture the same level of affection as its predecessor.

The character development in Beast Machines was notably darker and more complex. Unlike the more playful and character-driven narrative of Beast Wars, the stories in this series often explored themes of spirituality and existentialism. While these were compelling for some, they often alienated viewers expecting more straightforward action and adventure.

Animation Style and Plot Complexity

The animation quality received mixed reviews. The show utilized CGI technology, which was cutting-edge at the time, but some viewers found the visual models and aesthetics less appealing than the detailed and beloved hand-drawn elements of Beast Wars. This shift in style was a point of contention for many fans and critics.

The complex plot of Beast Machines was seen as overly convoluted. With heavy-handed storytelling and layered themes, the show struggled to resonate with audiences seeking simpler, more direct narratives. Additionally, the show didn't resolve many of its subplot arcs, leaving fans feeling unsatisfied and wanting more closure.

Improving Finale and Character Dynamics

There is a notable improvement in the later episodes of Beast Machines, especially from episode 6 onwards. The character evolution becomes more compelling as the show progresses. For instance, Rattrap, Cheetor, and Black Arachnia are seen as more mature and similar to their Beast Wars counterparts by the time the season progresses. Even Bat "Roar" is portrayed differently, evolving to become less annoying over time.

The transformation of Megatron is particularly interesting. While in Beast Wars, Megatron started as a joke and gradually evolved into a menacing villain, Beast Machines presents a more dangerous and ominous version. He transitions from a menacing character to a figure of such overwhelming power that fans were eager to see him leave the show. Similarly, Optimus Prime undergoes a significant change, starting as a very different character but eventually reclaiming his old self by the season finale.

Tankor’s Revival and Importance

A character that many fans actually appreciate in Beast Machines is Tankor. The show's creators breathed new life into him, making him a serious and formidable threat. While the details of his storyline remain a mystery, fans encourage viewers to watch the show to discover what makes this character so compelling.

In conclusion, while Beast Machines certainly had its flaws, it offers a unique take on the Transformers mythos. For those who prefer a more epic and morally complex narrative, it may well be worth giving it a second chance. The departure from the original Beast Wars and the introduction of new themes and character arcs make it a worthwhile exploration for both Transformers fans and newcomers alike.