The Worst Superhero of MCU: Analyzing Carol Danvers and Peni Parker's Troubled Histories

The Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has seen its share of memorable characters, each with unique stories and origins. However, some figures stand out as more controversial and less palatable than others. In this article, we delve into the tumultuous histories of two such characters: Peni Parker from the Sony Spider-Man animated film and Carol Danvers, aka Captain Marvel. By examining their origins, redesigns, and reception, we'll uncover why these characters might be considered the 'worst' of the MCU.

Peni Parker from the Sony Animated Movie Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

Among the vast array of Spider-Men across the multiverse, Peni Parker from Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse stands out as a character many consider problematic. One primary reason for this reception is the anime character design, which many fans find garbage. The character's mecha suit, known as Sp//dr, is widely criticized for being weird. Perhaps most embarassing is the name Pider-Man, which, without an 'S,' seems nonsensical to many. Ultimately, Peni's lackluster portrayal and unimpressive traits make her a character that many find disappointing in the Spider-Man multiverse.

Carol Danvers (Captain Marvel): A Character in Continuous Flux

If Peni Parker faces criticism, Carol Danvers (Captain Marvel), a long-standing and influential character, has endured a more complex journey filled with reboots and alterations. From her first iteration as Ms. Marvel to her current status as Captain Marvel, Danvers has undergone numerous reboots, each sparking controversy and debate within the comics and fan communities.

The Evolution of Carol Danvers as Ms. Marvel

Carol Danvers' first appearance as Ms. Marvel in MARVEL Superheroes #13 in 1968 marked the beginning of a long and often tumultuous career. Over the years, Ms. Marvel faced cancellation, brainwashing, and controversial storylines. One of the most infamous is the 1980 storyline where Carol Danvers was brainwashed, seduced, and impregnated by Marcus, son of the character Immortus. This storyline was particularly upsetting for fans at the time and continues to be a point of contention. The character's numerous reboots, totaling 12 according to Jason, reflect the struggles and reimaginings fans have faced.

Carol Danvers as Captain Marvel

>

Carol Danvers' rise to Captain Marvel has been marked by a series of reboots and reimaginings. Following her introduction as Ms. Marvel, Danvers reappeared as Warbird, an alcoholic character who left the Avengers in disgrace. This character was rebooted with the introduction of Captain Marvel in 2011, only to face further cancellations and reboots. Her journey from Ms. Marvel to Captain Marvel is a story of fan and editorial dissatisfaction, each iteration bringing fresh controversy and reimaginings of the character.

Conclusion and Reflection

Both Peni Parker and Carol Danvers have faced significant challenges and reimaginings, with each change bringing a new wave of controversy and mixed reception. Peni's character design and traits are often criticized, while Carol Danvers' character has undergone 12 major reboots, each aiming to please but often falling short. Despite their troubled histories, both characters remain significant within the larger context of the MCU and the broader superhero narrative. Whether these reimaginings make them the 'worst' superheroes is subjective, but it is clear that their complex backstories have made them more intriguing and thought-provoking in the eyes of fans and critics alike.