The Unlikely Reconciliation: Andromeda and Narcissa in a Post-Hogwarts World

Have you ever imagined that Andromeda and Narcissa, two prominent members of the Black family, would find a way to reconcile? While the idea may seem appealing, the real-world dynamics between these sisters suggest otherwise. Let's delve into why their relationship is more strained than reconcilable, based on existing canon and credible fan analysis.

Childhood Tensions and Family Views

Andromeda and Narcissa's childhood relationship is likely to have been far from close. The popular fan fiction film Sisters of House Black paints a picture of the two as closer than the canon source, Harry Potter. However, canon sources indicate that their relationship was more strained than depicted. This is largely due to their starkly differing views on the wizarding world and its interactions with muggles.

Andromeda was opposed to the family’s discriminatory views, marrying into the muggle world and subsequently disowning from the Black family. This likely made her feel out of place in her family environment. Children, especially young ones, are highly influenced by their parents. Therefore, it's reasonable to assume that Andromeda would have found it difficult to align with her family's opinions, especially regarding muggle rights. Narcissa, on the other hand, would have been more inclined to accept and support her parents' beliefs.

While both sisters may have tried to get along, their fundamental differences likely led to frequent disagreements and moments of frustration. These tensions would have been further amplified by the differing paths they chose in later life, making it even harder for them to find common ground.

Post-Disownment and Estrangement

Even if Andromeda and Narcissa were initially close, their relationship would have rapidly deteriorated after Andromeda's disownment. When Andromeda married a muggle-born, she essentially stood against her family’s values and beliefs. Narcissa chose to side with her parents by disowning Andromeda rather than staying true to her beliefs and accepting her sister’s marriage.

Contrary to popular fan fiction, Narcissa is not portrayed as being more subservient to Lucius Malfoy. Instead, she is known for her staunch agreement with Lucius’s intolerant and prejudiced views. Her marriage to Lucius Malfoy, a known Death Eater, further solidifies her position. It would have been nearly impossible for Andromeda to reconcile with Narcissa given the insults and disownment.

In essence, the choice made by Narcissa to deny her sister further cemented the estrangement between the two. Any attempt by Narcissa to reconcile would be seen as insincere, given her past actions and continued support of the Death Eater cause.

Post-Voldemort World and Public Perception

The aftermath of Voldemort's defeat added another layer of tension. The wizarding world, having experienced the horrors of the Dark Lord, would have a strong reaction against Death Eaters and sympathizers. This would include the Malfoy family, who were actively involved in Voldemort's regime. If the Malfoys had not gone to Azkaban, they would have faced widespread public hatred and condemnation. This scenario would make it even more difficult for Andromeda and Narcissa to bridge the emotional and ideological gaps that exist between them.

Andromeda's choice to marry a muggle and her subsequent disownment would have left a profound mark on her relationship with Narcissa. The public perception of the Malfoys would further exacerbate this divide, making it implausible for Andromeda to find forgiveness or reconciliation with her estranged sister.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the idea of reconciliation between Andromeda and Narcissa is fascinating, the real-world dynamics and existing canon paint a very different picture. Their differing views, Narcissa's support for the family's values over Andromeda's beliefs, and the public sentiment post-Voldemort's defeat all contribute to the improbability of their reconciliation.