The Succession Crisis: Would Westeros Accept Shaera or Crown Steffon Baratheon?

If Jaehaerys II Targaryen had passed away childless, the intricacies of the Westerosi succession would have been far more complex. The already strained Targaryen line, weakened by internal strife and political tensions, would have faced significant challenges in determining the next ruler. This article explores the scenarios where either Shaera Targaryen or Steffon Baratheon could have ascended to the Iron Throne, and the implications of each.

Shaera Targaryen as Queen

Shaera Targaryen, as the daughter of Jaehaerys II, would have a legitimate claim to the throne. However, her acceptance as queen would depend on the prevailing political landscape at the time of her ascension. The support of both the nobility and the common folk would be crucial, especially considering the traditional gender biases of Westerosi society.

Support for Shaera

Despite her legitimacy, Shaera’s path to the Iron Throne would not be smooth. In a society where females have historically been excluded from ruling, her status as a female ruler would likely face substantial resistance. Some more traditional houses might perceive her as unfit to rule, leading to potential civil unrest or political maneuvering against her.

Challenges for Shaera

The challenges for Shaera would extend beyond mere political resistance. She would need to navigate the complex web of alliances and rivalries within the Seven Kingdoms. Her ability to secure these alliances would be crucial in maintaining her reign.

Steffon Baratheon as King

Steffon Baratheon, being a prominent lord and a member of a powerful family, would have a strong backing, particularly among those who favored a male ruler. His claim could be strengthened by the belief that a king from a major house like the Baratheons would bring stability to the realm.

Claim from the Baratheons

The Baratheons’ influence in Westeros would play a significant role in this scenario. Steffon could seek alliances and support from other powerful families, potentially leading to a shift in power dynamics in Westeros. These alliances would help in establishing Steffon’s legitimacy and securing his position on the Iron Throne.

Political Action and Alliances

If Steffon were to ascend to the Iron Throne, he would need to engage in political maneuvering, forming alliances with influential houses to solidify his rule. Potential allies might include the Starks, Lannisters, and other powerful families with which the Baratheons have long-standing relationships.

Conclusion

The acceptance of either Shaera or Steffon would hinge on the political landscape and the support from major houses. Both scenarios could lead to significant conflict, with the War of the Five Kings being a possible iteration of such a power struggle. Ultimately, the outcome would depend on who could garner the greatest support from the influential lords and ladies of Westeros.

Moreover, if Steffon were to ascend to the Iron Throne, his marriage to a Velaryon would likely be insisted upon as a way to shore up his legitimacy. The Velaryon family is known for their strong naval capabilities and noble lineage, which would provide Steffon with additional support and prestige.

The post-Rhaenyra Westerosi seemed to prefer males on the Iron Throne, as they did in the aftermath of the Dance of the Dragons. Rhaelle Targaryen, Steffon’s mother, would also be a formidable figure in this scenario. She might be named queen regent until Steffon is ready to rule, assuming Jaehaerys II’s death was sudden enough to necessitate such a transition.

A coronation without a male heir would lead to a significant fragmentation in Westeros. A peaceful and united Westeros under King Steffon would have been better prepared for the challenges ahead. Robert would be raised in King's Landing as the Crown Prince, likely developing a different personality and demeanor than he might have under Ned Stark. Tywin Lannister, as Hand to Jaehaerys II, would likely continue to serve as Hand to Robert, shaping his early years and leadership.