The Most Toxic Shonen Communities: Tanjiro's Harem vs. MHA Community

Shonen communities in anime are often infamous for being toxic, but which one takes the crown? This article explores two of the most contentious communities: the Tanjiro Harem and the My Hero Academia (MHA) community, delving into the reasons behind their toxicity and the impact on the fandom.

Tanjiro Harem: Where Romance Takes Over

While I deeply love Demon Slayer (Kimetsu no Yaiba), the community around it has gone a little too far with the harem for Tanjiro. The sheer number of ship theories not only overshadows the story but also leads to debates and conflicts within the fanbase. Let's break down the harem:

Ship Theories: A Comprehensive List

Here is a comprehensive list of the ships for Tanjiro:

Tanjiro x Nezuko - Good 'ol sweet home vibes! Tanjiro x Zenitsu - A little canon, honestly Tanjiro x Inosuke - Why does this happen? Tanjiro x Tomioka (FBI OPEN UP!!!) - Need some bleach. Tanjiro x Rengoku - Met for like ten seconds. Tanjiro x Rengoku x Giyuu - Where did I put that holy water? Tanjiro x Shinobu - Meh. Tanjiro x Kanao - Finally something canon and legal. Tanjiro x Kanao x Shinobu - Back to illegal. Tanjiro x Sanemi - I- I don't. I just... WHY!!! Tanjiro x Genya - Well, at least it's legal. Tanjiro x Genya x Sanemi - Incest and illegal!!! Tanjiro x Sabito - Why is Sabito a top! Y'now what fck it. Tanjiro x Makomo - How old is Makomo! Tanjiro x Giyuu x Sabito - I immediately think of AAAAAAAAAAAAA!!! Tanjiro x Muzan - Why... just why. Tanjiro x Akaza - He killed Rengoku. Why would you even- Tanjiro x Sumiyoshi - Bruh, they're the same person why? Tanjiro x Muichiro - That's-... actually understandable. Tanjiro x Aoi - Meh, that's good. Tanjiro x Mitsuri - You all know full well- Tanjiro x Shinobu x Mitsuri - Back to illegal. Tanjiro x Obanai - They don't even like each other!! Tanjiro x Yoriichi - STOP!!! Tanjiro x Douma - They never even met!!!

While some of these ships are understandable, others feel super random, weird, or illegal. Tanjiro's character is incredibly shippable, but the obsession with creating these ships overshadows the actual content of the show. It's time to stop and appreciate the story for what it is.

The MHA Community: A Battle of Ship Theories

On the other hand, the My Hero Academia (MHA) community is infamous for intense debates and toxicity, especially regarding ship theories. Unlike Tanjiro's harem, MHA's focus is more on the themes of heroism and coming-of-age stories, but the ship theories take center stage in fan discussions.

Why MHA's Ships Are Controversial

One example of this toxicity is the reaction to a Kacchako fanart. I stumbled upon it on Instagram and found it endearing, not because I ship Kacchako, but because it showcased a cute dynamic. However, the comments were filled with hate, with people suggesting that the artist should have their arms chopped off. This highlights the lack of respect and understanding for different opinions and ship theories.

Shipping in the MHA community is often taken too seriously, with fans tearing down others' theories and trying to convince others that their theory is the "most canon." This type of behavior fosters a toxic environment where fans are unable to coexist peacefully.

Conclusion

Shonen communities can be passionate and enthusiastic, but the Tanjiro Harem and MHA communities both showcase the darkest sides of fandom. Tanjiro's harem has become a contentious topic, overshadowing the story and leading to discussions that feel forced and random. Meanwhile, the MHA community's obsession with ship theories has fostered a culture of toxicity, with fans attacking each other over differing opinions.

Ultimately, it's important for fans to respect each other's opinions and focus on the themes and messages of the show rather than getting lost in ship theories. This can help create a more positive and inclusive community for all.