Introduction

In the animated film The Lion King, Kiara's choice to exile herself with Kovu was a pivotal moment in her life, but what would have happened if Simba and Nala had made this choice for her? This article explores the potential consequences of such an action, focusing on the emotional, political, and familial repercussions. We will delve into the dynamics between Simba, Nala, Kiara, and Kovu, and how their relationships would have evolved under these circumstances.

Simba's Decision: A Stupid Move

Simba and Nala's decision to exile Kiara with Kovu would have been a significant and ultimately misguided move. While Simba's intentions were likely out of concern for his daughter's safety and to protect the Pridelands from the unstable regime of Scar's remaining followers, the consequences could have been far more detrimental than beneficial.

Simba's Intention and Leniency

Simba, as the rightful heir to the throne, would have faced immense pressure from his father's followers and the Hyenas to maintain the status quo. The idea that Kovu was framed and that Kiara did not act in a way that warranted banishment would make Simba appear weak and indecisive. This leniency would further undermine his leadership, likely leading to internal conflicts and public mistrust.

The Outcome for Kiara and Kovu

The reality is that Kiara and Kovu would have faced a precarious journey and a uncertain future. Their pride in the Outlands would have to be built from scratch, and their path would be fraught with challenges and dangers.

Building a New Pride

While Kiara and Kovu would manage to establish a new pride, it would not be without its tribulations. The Outlands, known for its harsh terrain and unforgiving climate, would pose significant logistical and survival issues for the new pride. They would have to navigate the dangerous waters of inter-predator relationships and the constant threat of encroaching human settlements. The image of a new pride being founded by two outcasts would likely cast a shadow over their attempts to build a stable and prosperous life.

Simba's and Nala's Long-term Consequences

The true impact of exile would not be immediately apparent. In the short term, Simba and Nala's kingdom would appear amicable, as the initial excitement of Kiara's absence would give way to a sense of normalcy. However, the roots of discontent and unrest would remain beneath the surface.

Zira's Revenge and Legacy

Without Kiara's return and the potential for resolution, Zira's legacy of conflict would endure. Zira, now free of her primary enemy, would target Simba as her main adversary. Her desire for revenge would fuel a never-ending cycle of violence, potentially involving her daughter, Vitani. This continuation of the cycle of vengeance would cast a long shadow over the Pridelands, making peace and stability unattainable.

Aftermath and Legacy

Even with Zira's eventual demise, the remnants of her influence would linger, and Vitani would carry on her mother's legacy. The Pridelands would never truly recover from the political and emotional turmoil, and the cycle of violence would continue, potentially involving future generations.

Simba and Nala, now having lost their only heir, would navigate a future characterized by regret and a lingering sense of failure. The Pridelands would suffer from war and instability, with no clear path to recovery or peace. The legacy of Kiara's absence would echo through time, a testament to the choices made by her parents.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the decision to exile Kiara with Kovu would have had dire consequences for all involved. From the broad landscapes of the Pridelands to the intimate journeys of Simba and Nala, the repercussions would be far-reaching and profound. The story of The Lion King would take a dark turn, filled with tragedy and loss, but also the enduring hope for redemption and the possibility of a better future.