The Dursleys and a Majorca Holiday: A Speculative Look

Would the Dursleys have taken Harry with them to Majorca in the second book? This is a question often pondered by fans of the Harry Potter series. In the book, it is mentioned that if Dobby had not interfered with their plans, the Dursleys were planning to use their commission from a holiday home deal to buy a house in Majorca. However, it is highly unlikely that the Dursleys would have brought Harry along with them.

Why Harry Wasn’t Welcomed in Majorca

The Dursleys viewed Harry purely as a liability and an unwanted burden. They treated him with the utmost disdain, as evidenced by their reactions when Dobby revealed his presence. Given their attitude, it is inconceivable that they would have welcomed Harry into their vacation plans, no matter the destination. For them, their holiday was all about relaxation and self-indulgence, not looked at through the lens of responsibility or family values.

A More Likely Scenario: Harry Staying with Aunt Petunia and Mrs. Figg

Instead of bringing Harry along, the Dursleys would likely have left him with his Aunt Petunia and Mrs. Figg when they went to Majorca. Mrs. Figg, who looked after Harry when the Dursleys were away, would have been a natural choice to care for him. However, there are a few factors that could change this decision. For instance, if Mrs. Figg were unavailable or if the Dursleys felt it was not appropriate to inconvenience her, they might be forced into bringing Harry along.

The Implications of a Majorca Holiday without Harry

A holiday would have been ruined for the Dursleys had Harry been along, as they are extremely intolerant of his presence and conduct. Even in the brief time he spent away from Privet Drive, they often resorted to extreme measures, like hiring Dobby to keep him away or pleading with Aunt Petunia to take care of him. Their wishes for a stress-free and luxurious vacation would surely be compromised by Harry's interference.

An Unlikely But Possible Scenario: Local Care in Majorca

Given the circumstances, it is plausible that Mrs. Catwoman, as a local caretaker or familiar face, might be approached to look after Harry for a week while the Dursleys were on holiday. Mrs. Catwoman, in this context, could be imagined as a kindly but strict caregiver who might be more willing to help out than Aunt Petunia or Mrs. Figg. This scenario respects the reality that the Dursleys would not sacrifice their vacation for Harry, but it adds a layer of community and familiarity to care for him.

The Weasleys as a Last Resort

Another possibility is that the Dursleys may have decided to let Harry go and stay with the Weasleys. The Weasleys are magical and often more lenient and kind, which could have appealed to the Dursleys as an alternative. However, it is unlikely that the Dursleys would have willingly let Harry stay with the Weasleys; such a decision would likely have been forced upon them due to unforeseen circumstances, such as the scarcity of other caretakers.

Ultimately, the Dursleys' refusal to include Harry in their Majorca holiday reflects their narrow-minded and selfish nature, prioritizing their own enjoyment over their responsibilities. The reality of the situation suggests that Harry would have remained at Privet Drive, cared for by Mrs. Figg or possibly with a temporary local guardian, while the Dursleys enjoyed their well-deserved time off.