The Debate on Cloning Emperor Palpatine Alive After Episode IX: The Rise of Skywalker

In the concluding episode of the Star Wars franchise, The Rise of Skywalker, Emperor Palpatine’s final fate was left in a state of uncertainty. As Rey channels Sidious’s own Force lightning back at him, the iconic villain is vaporized, along with the Sith Eternal cultists involved in the cloning experiments. While some argue that bringing Palpatine back would not do the franchise any favors, this article explores the possibility that his spirit lived on and considers alternatives.

Disney's Current Stance and Criticisms

Disney's decision to bring Emperor Palpatine back in The Rise of Skywalker has been heavily criticized. Critics argue that bringing him back was a mistake, showcasing a lack of creativity and original thought. Rather than resurrecting him, it would have been more effective to have him meet his demise and develop new First Order or Sith villains for future sequels. However, for fans of Palpatine, there is a potential alternative scenario that is worth exploring.

The Secret Cloning Facility Theory

A faction of Star Wars fans and writers have proposed the idea of a secret cloning facility hidden on Byss or another planet, possibly similar to the one hinted at in the Legends. This secret bunker could have been prepped with triggers to create a new cloned body for Emperor Palpatine in case the Emperor was ever defeated. This would allow the character to return, potentially enriching the narrative in future stories. However, for the franchise's longevity, it is crucial to consider the implications of such a return.

Imposing Limitations on Palpatine's Resurrection

While the idea of bringing back Emperor Palpatine is intriguing, it's crucial to remember that it must be handled carefully. If his return is to be impactful, it must happen under specific conditions. For instance, his resurrection could be limited to a single timeline or a specific purpose. This would help maintain the coherence of the story and avoid overusing a powerful character that risks diluting the suspense and impact of his original death.

Developing Future Villains and Storylines

No matter how the story unfolds, Disney needs to focus on developing new, compelling villains for the next trilogy. This would allow the franchise to continue evolving and maintaining the audience's interest. Instead of reviving Palpatine, they could push the boundaries of the storytelling, exploring dark and complex characters who could challenge the main protagonists in new and exciting ways.

Conclusion

The resurrection of Emperor Palpatine is a contentious topic among Star Wars fans and critics alike. While the secret cloning facility theory offers a thrilling alternative, it must be treated with caution to avoid undermining the original narrative. For the franchise to thrive, it is essential to explore new villains and storylines that will continue to captivate audiences and push the boundaries of the consent tradition in science fiction and fantasy.