The Alternative Fate of Anakin Skywalker and the Jedi Order

Have you ever wondered what would happen if Anakin Skywalker, the Chosen One, decided to share his marriage to Padmé Amidala and the news of her pregnancy with the Jedi Council? What if he asked for their help to save her from dying?

Penalties for Leaving the Jedi Order

A quiz question for you: What is the penalty for leaving the Jedi Order? The answer might surprise you: nothing. This is not a secret; other Jedi have left the Order in the past. The reason Anakin did not leave was not because of any formal penalty, but because his heart and soul were deeply intertwined with the Jedi way. For him, serving as a Jedi was his life's mission, his way to bring peace to the galaxy.

The Jedi Order’s Strict Policies

Despite the lack of formal penalties, Anakin would have faced significant resistance if he had attempted to leave the Order for personal reasons. The Jedi were known for their strict policies and did not easily tolerate such disruptions. For instance, when Ahsoka Tano was forced to leave the Order, she was not apologized to for her departure. Even Ki-Adi-Mundi, a Jedi with a known family, was allowed this exception due to the unique circumstances of his species. However, this was the exception rather than the rule.

Retaining His Mission

Throughout the series, Anakin’s primary goal was to bring peace to the galaxy. It would have been perfect if he could have achieved this while also maintaining his family. However, the reality was that his duties as a Jedi could not be compromised for personal reasons. Any attempt to leave would have meant the loss of his role as the Chosen One, a role he believed he was destined for.

Alternatives to the Current Events

Imagine a different outcome. If Anakin had shared his intentions with the Council, it would not have been shocking, as many members were already aware of his private life. The crucial point would have been the Council's reaction and what they would do with Anakin. Instead, the ultimate revelation would have been the true nature of the conflict. If the Council had been aware of Anakin's family, they would have faced a crucial decision about trusting him with their knowledge of the Sith's true agenda.

With this knowledge, Anakin could have revealed the visions he was having about Padmé’s wellbeing. He could have disclosed that Darth Sidious had told him he could save her. The Council would have been able to uncover the deception and expose Darth Sidious as the true foe. This revelation would have led to the destruction of the Sith, and Anakin would have been recognized as the Chosen One who helped bring balance to the Force.

The Council, realizing Anakin's true value, might have given him an exception in terms of having a family. This would not have been too far from the current situation where family was allowed for some Jedi. Such an outcome would have been a victory for Anakin and the Jedi Order, leading to a happier and more fulfilling ending for all involved.