Should Vegeta Have Fought Android 18 During the Buu Saga?

The question of whether Vegeta should have fought Android 18 during the Buu Saga is an intriguing one, sparking discussions among fans of the Dragon Ball Z series. Let's explore the potential benefits and drawbacks of adding such a rematch to the story.

Character Development

Throughout the series, Vegeta’s character has undergone significant growth and transformation. A rematch with Android 18 could have served as a strong representation of his character development. Since the Cell Saga, where his focus on strength and pride were all-consuming, Vegeta has evolved into a more mature and responsible character, both as a father and as a husband. A rematch with 18 would present an opportunity to showcase this evolution and the internal struggles Vegeta faced in balancing Saiyan pride with his family obligations.

Thematic Elements

The Buu Saga emphasizes themes of redemption and the importance of family. Introducing a rematch between Vegeta and Android 18 could have deepened these themes. It would highlight Vegeta’s internal struggle, illustrating how he grapples with his Saiyan sense of honor and his new-found responsibilities within his family. This narrative would have resonated strongly with audiences, adding a layer of complexity to Vegeta's character and the overall series.

Power Dynamics

By the time of the Buu Saga, Vegeta had achieved the ultimate form of a Super Saiyan: the Ascended Super Saiyan. This means he was significantly stronger than when he faced Cell in the Cell Saga. A rematch would have allowed the series to explore the differences in their power levels and fighting styles, providing a richer and more engaging subplot. It would have been an opportunity to showcase Vegeta’s advanced combat techniques and to further elevate his role as one of the most formidable characters in the series.

Comic Relief and Rivalry

Vegeta’s rivalry with other characters often serves as a source of comic relief and tension. A match with Android 18, who is known for her strength and capability, could have added an interesting dynamic to the story. It would have provided a subplot that could have been both fun and engaging, balancing the serious tone of the Buu Saga’s overarching narrative with moments of humor and competition.

Impact on the Story

Integrating a rematch into the Buu Saga would have required careful consideration. The urgency of the events surrounding Buu made it challenging to introduce additional plotlines. However, if handled correctly, a rematch could have enriched the narrative by providing additional depth and character development. For example, it could have allowed for deeper exploration of Vegeta’s relationships and provided more opportunities for moral dilemmas that add to the overall story’s thematic elements.

In summary, while a rematch between Vegeta and Android 18 could have been entertaining and beneficial for character development, it would have needed to be seamlessly integrated into the existing storyline. If done properly, this addition could have enhanced the storytelling and provided a more well-rounded and engaging narrative.

However, it's worth noting that in the original series, Vegeta was indeed not strong enough to defeat Android 18 in their initial encounter, even as a Super Saiyan. This was due to 18's speed and mental combat skills. Vegeta's subsequent growth and transformation into an Ascended Super Saiyan during the Buu Saga made him a much more formidable opponent by that time. Therefore, a rematch would not have made sense given the overall power levels and the progression of the characters.