Saber's Feelings towards Shirou in Fate Stay Night: Dispelling Misconceptions

As we delve into the complex dynamics between Saber and Shirou in the anime series Fate Stay Night, a common misconception arises: that Saber hates Shirou. However, this couldn't be further from the truth, at least based on the overarching narrative in the Visual Novel (VN) and the original anime adaptation.

Saber’s Genuine Feelings for Shirou

While Saber may not openly express her feelings, the Fate Stay Night series portrays a different side of her emotions. In the Ultralocal (UBW Route) and Heaven's Feel Route, Saber is depicted as fond of Shirou. This fondness even morphs into love in the Fate Route, a narrative that showcases the depth of their relationship.

It is crucial to understand that Saber's "hate" is more of an annoyance caused by Shirou's tendency to put himself in harm's way in order to protect and fight for her. This trait, while admirable, makes her job of protecting him more challenging and less manageable. However, this inclination is rooted in something much deeper and more sincere than mere annoyance.

To What Extent Does Shirou Hate Him?

Shirou's willingness to throw himself into danger is not a matter of choice, but rather a result of severe mental trauma and a deeply ingrained belief in the joy of saving others. Fate Stay Night reveals that Shirou is, in fact, insane, a fact that the anime adaptations sometimes downplay.

Shirou's actions are motivated by an extreme sense of selflessness and a profound desire to experience joy, which he can only achieve by saving others. This psychological condition, which he developed due to traumatic events, including the Fourth Holy Grail War, leads him to disregard his own safety. Despite his intentions, Shirou is not intentionally putting himself in harm's way but rather cannot help it due to his mental state.

Saber's Perspective on Shirou

From Saber's perspective, Shirou's actions are not driven by a malicious desire to hate her or others. Rather, they are the result of his intense internal conflict and the trauma he has endured. Saber, while sometimes exasperated by Shirou's actions, does not hate him for his behavior. Instead, she appreciates his selflessness and even goes so far as to train him, a rare show of trust and belief in him.

Not only does Saber train Shirou, but evidence of their close bond is also seen in the original Visual Novel (VN) where they share a tender moment. In the Fate Route, they even became intimate, suggesting a deeper connection and mutual respect.

Conclusion

In summary, Saber does not hate Shirou. Her feelings and dedication to him are far more complex. Beyond her annoyance at his willingness to take risks for others, there is a genuine love and appreciation for his selfless nature. Understanding this helps dispel the misconception that Saber harbors a strong resentment towards Shirou. Instead, it reveals a relationship rooted in deep emotional connection and mutual respect, even in the face of challenges and misunderstandings.

Having a well-rounded understanding of Saber and Shirou's relationship is key to appreciating the depth and authenticity of their journey in the realm of Fate Stay Night.