Saber Artoria vs Rider Astolfo: Who Would Win?

The matchup between Saber Artoria Pendragon and Rider Astolfo from the Fate/Apocrypha series is an intriguing one, as both are powerful Servants with distinct abilities and strengths. Understanding their unique combat styles and capabilities can help us predict potential outcomes in a hypothetical battle.

(Character Analysis)

Saber Artoria Pendragon

Class: Saber

Strengths: Artoria is renowned for her exceptional swordsmanship, high agility, and powerful Noble Phantasm Excalibur, which can inflict massive damage. She also possesses strong defensive capabilities and is a skilled tactician.

Noble Phantasm: Excalibur, a legendary sword that unleashes a powerful beam of light capable of devastating opponents and serving as one of the most iconic attacks in the Fate series.

Rider Astolfo

Class: Rider

Strengths: Astolfo is known for his agility, charm, and the ability to summon his Noble Phantasm Hippogriff, which grants him flight. He is also exceptionally resourceful, possessing a variety of magical tools.

Noble Phantasm: The Hippogriff, a creature that allows Astolfo to fly and attack from the air. He also wields the Cursed Tools, which can disrupt opponents.

Analysis

Combat Style

Artoria's combat style: Artoria excels in direct combat, harnessing her sword skills and powerful attacks. Her strength and combat experience are her primary advantages.

Astolfo's combat style: Astolfo relies on agility, trickery, and mobility. His ability to fly and his resourcefulness make him a formidable opponent who can strike from above and evade enemy attacks.

Strength vs. Agility

If the battle is a direct confrontation: Artoria's raw power and combat experience might give her the upper hand. Her strength and agility, combined with her tactical prowess, can overwhelm Astolfo in a close-range battle.

If Astolfo can use his cunning and magical tools effectively: He might be able to outmaneuver Artoria, flying above her and using his Cursed Tools to disrupt her. However, Astolfo's efforts would need to be meticulously planned to achieve any lasting advantage.

Tactics

If Astolfo can effectively use his cunning and magical tools, he might find ways to outmaneuver Artoria. However, Artoria's experience as a knight can help her anticipate and counter Astolfo's tactics. Her tactical acumen and familiarity with battle can make her a challenging opponent even when faced with a more agile and versatile foe.

Conclusion

While Artoria has the advantage in terms of raw power and combat skills: Astolfo's versatility and agility could allow him to turn the tide in his favor. The outcome of their battle would depend on the specific circumstances, including the environment and their strategies.

In a straight fight: Artoria is likely to win due to her superior combat skills and endurance. However, Astolfo could potentially outsmart her with the right approach, using his mobility, magical tools, and elaborate tactics to gain the upper hand.

The true victor would likely be the Servant who adapts best to the unpredictable dynamics of battle, blending their strengths with strategic thinking and adaptability.