Review and Analysis of Detective Conan: A Personal Take

Having been a fan of Detective Conan for years, I cannot help but share my thoughts on what makes this series both a staple and a subject of scrutiny in the world of mysteries and detective-themed media.

Why The Series Can Miss the Mark

Firstly, it is important to note that Detective Conan is an extended series, which spans a considerable number of episodes and chapters. For viewers who find the story lacking depth, the length can indeed be a barrier. While my personal experience with it as a child was highly enjoyable, it might not be the best choice for those looking for a quick fix or a deep, intricate mystery.

Personal Insights as a Longtime Reader

I have been binge-reading the manga series since it began, currently sitting at Chapter 460. The story's journey holds a nostalgic value for me, as it was a significant part of my childhood. Despite its numerous strengths, it also has its notable weaknesses.

Challenges in Realism and Logic

One major critique I have of Detective Conan is its approach to realism and logic. The show often goes against what is considered realistic human behavior. For example, in a scenario where a man is dying after being struck from behind, the show suggests that the natural human response would be to create a puzzle or game to send clues. This is a flawed representation of survival instinct, as humans typically aim to survive first and foremost.

Moreover, the series is known for being less realistic in its portrayal of a 17-year-old boy who possesses extensive knowledge in various fields, including detective skills. This unrealistic premise makes it difficult to take the series seriously as a detective-themed story.

Other Criticisms

Other aspects of Detective Conan, such as the portrayal of the police forces and the methods used by criminals, are also worthy of critique. The idea that detectives would listen to a child's reasoning and still allow murders to occur is unrealistic and adds to the inconsistent logic in the narrative.

Comparison to Other Works

Some viewers draw comparisons to works like Sherlock Holmes, suggesting that Detective Conan cannot match the level of satisfaction found in those mystery stories. However, I believe this comparison is unfair. Detective Conan is vastly different from works like Sherlock Holmes or Classroom of the Elite, each having its unique style and satisfaction level.

Conclusion: Enjoyment vs. Realism

Reflecting on my experience with Detective Conan, I am a fan who enjoys the show for its entertainment value. It offers a breather from the complexities of life and provides a sense of satisfaction in its story endings. However, it is important to recognize that the show, while enjoyable, often deviates from realistic portrayals of human behavior and the criminal mind.

If you are looking for a fun read or a casual escape from the complexities of daily life, Detective Conan is worth giving a try. Just be aware that if you are seeking a story that aligns closely with human reality and logic, this may not be the series for you.