Reflections on Fullmetal Alchemist: Continuation or Separate Story?

The world of Fullmetal Alchemist continues to captivate the hearts and minds of fans around the globe. Long-time viewers and newcomers alike debate the merit of a continuation of the series, particularly after its successful and conclusion-oriented finale. In this article, we will explore the pros and cons of a new continuation, as well as the merits of a separate story within the same universe.

Is a Continuation Necessary for Fullmetal Alchemist?

The argument for a continuation of Fullmetal Alchemist often stems from the lingering curiosity about what happens to the main characters after the war against the Homunculi. Fans yearn to see Edward and Alphonse embark on their journey to explore the world and delve deeper into alchemy. However, the series has already achieved a satisfying conclusion with its exploration of the ethical and moral implications of alchemy, as well as the personal growth of its protagonists.

Some enthusiasts argue that a continuation is a great opportunity to craft a new narrative and explore different aspects of the Fullmetal Alchemist universe. They suggest that the new adventures of the brothers could bring fresh perspectives and stories that fans can eagerly anticipate. However, the risk of marring the beautiful ending of the original series cannot be ignored.

The risk is particularly high given that the series’ narrative arc was designed to be a complete and self-contained story. Edward's loss of his alchemy ability and the subsequent changes in his and Alphonse’s lives make it difficult to justify a direct continuation. While it is theoretically possible to craft a compelling new story, the chances of improving upon the existing narrative are slim, and the risk of ruining the well-crafted conclusion is significant.

Exploring a New Story within the Same Universe

An alternative approach, which I find more appealing, is to explore a new story within the same universe. This way, the continuity of the series can be maintained without directly continuing the main plot. A new cast can emerge, with cameo appearances or references to the original characters, allowing fans to feel connected to the series while enjoying new adventures and storylines.

This approach has been successfully implemented in other popular series where a new cast is introduced, leading to different story arcs and plot developments. Examples include the Spider-Man movies, where different characters embody the Peter Parker persona (such as Miles Morales), and the Final Fantasy series, where different characters explore the world and bring new dimensions to the story.

Respecting the Series’ Achievements

Frankly, I am content with where the Fullmetal Alchemist series ended. Both Edward Elric and Alphonse Elric achieved their goals: thwarting the Homunculi and regaining as much of their original forms as possible. Their time in the spotlight was brought to a satisfying conclusion. It wouldn't be appropriate for the title Fullmetal Alchemist to be used again since the title bearer, Edward, no longer possesses alchemy. Instead, a new title or a different story arc could capture the essence of the character's legacy without directly continuing the original narrative.

The characters' journeys have come to a natural end, and any new story should reflect that. Fans would be more satisfied with a new narrative that pays homage to the original while moving forward into new and intriguing directions.

In conclusion, while a continuation is certainly a possibility, the risks involved outweigh the potential rewards. A new story within the same universe, with a fresh cast and strong references to the original characters, would be a more thoughtful and satisfying approach. Fullmetal Alchemist has achieved greatness in its conclusion and does not require any further continuation. Let us leave it as it is, a cherished memory in the hearts of its fans.

Thank you for reading! Have a good day!