Opinions on The Last Jedi: A Disappointing Chapter in Star Wars History

Introduction

Since its release in 2017, The Last Jedi has been a controversial and polarizing entry in the Star Wars saga. This article aims to explore various opinions about the movie, examining its reception among critics and fans. We’ll analyze the reasons for its criticism and why some consider it a significant part of Star Wars history despite the backlash.

Why the Criticism?

Many viewers and critics found The Last Jedi to be a disappointment, citing issues with pacing, writing, and character development.

1. Horrible Pacing

A prominent theme among critics is the film's perceived lackluster and confusing pacing. For instance, one reviewer stated, “The Last Jedi just doesn’t fit. This scene could have been replaced by Luke mourning over his best friend's death. Nobody needed a creature that moans in pleasure when milked.” This sentiment suggests that the movie's storytelling felt disjointed and rushed, failing to connect smoothly with the audience.

2. Different Writing Style

Another criticism stems from the feelings that the screenplay was inconsistent with the earlier entries. As one reviewer noted, “It’s a completely different writing style. It just doesn’t fit.” The script for The Last Jedi was seen as a departure from the previous trilogies, which some fans found disappointing.

Rewriting Star Wars?

Since The Last Jedi’s release, there have been ongoing debates about the direction of the Star Wars franchise. Some argue that Disney and Lucasfilm were trying to distance themselves from the established tradition.

1. Distancing from the Skywalkers

One fan’s opinion was particularly critical of this approach, stating, “Since it is part of the Skywalker Saga why were they trying to trash the Skywalker name? That to me is the only point that needs to be made. Finish the Saga and close out their story. Then branch off with new stories and characters.” This perspective emphasizes the importance of maintaining the legacy of the Skywalker lineage.

Personal Reactions and Comparisons

Personal opinions on The Last Jedi range from outright dislike to a more nuanced appreciation. Below are some insightful perspectives:

Experiencing Disappointment

Several viewers found The Last Jedi to be a significant letdown. One reviewer noted, “I hated it. It sucked in every way imaginable. They should have left the movies alone after the first trilogy. They’re classic movies that meant so much to me growing up. Especially the first two.” This viewpoint illustrates how hard it is to change long-standing beloved franchises.

Seeking Fresh Perspectives

However, not all viewers felt the same way. Some enjoyed The Last Jedi as a fresh and innovative addition to the saga. One reviewer commented, “I enjoyed The Last Jedi as a fun space adventure that didn’t retread ground and didn’t pander to nerd wish fulfillment. It took the story in new directions instead of being about wish-fulfillment and trying to either one-up Lucas’ original story or simply retelling it.” This perspective highlights the diversity of opinions and the potential for a more open-ended interpretation of the franchise.

Conclusion

The release of The Last Jedi sparked significant debate about the future of the Star Wars franchise. While some view it as a disappointing chapter, others see it as an opportunity for innovation and a new direction for the series. The Star Wars saga remains a beloved and influential cultural icon, with opinions ranging from passionate support to bitter disappointment.

As the franchise continues to evolve, it will be interesting to see how The Last Jedi and its reception are remembered in the annals of Star Wars history.

Keywords: The Last Jedi, Star Wars, Skywalker Saga