Why Do the Gods of Asgard Consider Asgardians Immortal If They Aren't in Marvel Comics?

This question delves into a fascinating but somewhat misguided perspective of the Marvel Universe. It intertwines with the broader themes of immortality, divinity, and narrative choice within the vast comic book landscape. Let us explore the complexities of this notion within the context of Marvel comics and Norse mythology.

Marvel Universe's Approach to Immortality

Despite the frequent crossover and collaboration of mythological entities, the Marvel Universe (MCU) gives its own unique spin on these ancient deities. It is important to first understand that the concept of immortality is not a strict criterion for inclusion in the MCU. While gods and goddesses from various mythologies are depicted, their portrayal often diverges from the original legends to align with the narrative arcs of Marvel's stories.

Mythological Pantheons in Marvel Comics

Gods and goddesses, such as Zeus and Athena, do not necessarily consider Asgardians immortal simply because they do not appear in the Marvel Comics. This misconception might arise from the dual nature of these beings - they can be both comic book characters and mythological entities. However, within the Marvel Universe, these characters often exist as part of the narrative rather than being rigidly defined by their mythological counterparts.

Examples Beyond Asgardians

For instance, Hercules, a pivotal figure in Greek mythology, has adapted to different forms within Marvel. Often appearing as an on-and-off-again Avenger, Hercules' fate and status are more fluid within the comic book world. Similarly, Ares, the Olympian God of War, has also been depicted as an Avenger, showcasing the MCU's tendency to reinterpret and incorporate mythological lore.

Specificity of Immortality in Norse and Greek Myths

The concept of immortality and its nature can vary significantly between different mythologies. In Norse mythology, Asgardians, particularly those associated with the Allfather Odin and his realm, are often depicted with specific elements that suggest an extended lifespan but not absolute immortality.

Golden Apples and Ambrosia

Both Asgardians and Olympians have dependencies that keep them youthful and vibrant. In Norse mythology, the Golden Apples of Idunn, harvested by the goddess Idunn, are said to grant eternal youth. In Greek mythology, the deities feed on ambrosia, a divine food that also keeps them youthful and immortal. However, this does not necessarily mean they are divine in the same sense as other mythological gods, just that they possess specific means to maintain their vitality.

No Absolute Immortality in the MCU

In the broader context of the Marvel Universe, character immortality is not a universal trait. While Thor and other Asgardians maintain a high lifespan and vigor, they, like other Marvel characters, are not beyond the reach of the supernatural and physical forces. The narrative decisions in the MCU often prioritize storytelling over strict adherence to mythological norms, leading to a mixture of divine and mortal characteristics among the gods and goddesses.

Conclusion: Narrative and Imagery

The perception that other gods consider Asgardians immortal due to not appearing in Marvel Comics stems from a limited understanding of both the narrative choices made by Marvel and the varied interpretations of mythological deities. While Norse and Greek gods in the Marvel Universe often rely on specific items to maintain their vitality, their status as immortals in the strictest sense is not a universal attribute across all stories and sub-universes.

Exploring the mythological elements in the Marvel Universe reveals a rich tapestry of storytelling that deftly blends ancient lore with contemporary comic book narratives. Whether this interpretation is accurate or not, it invites readers and fans to engage with these characters and their worlds in a more nuanced and fascinating way.