Jonathan Joestars Stand: Fact or Fan Theory?
Does Jonathan Joestar Have a Stand?
The question of whether Jonathan Joestar, the protagonist of JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, possesses a stand has been a topic of debate among fans for years. Some argue that he does not, while others believe that he does, relying on various sources to support their claims. This article explores both sides of the debate, providing a comprehensive overview of the argument that Jonathan indeed has a stand.
Fan Perspectives: Jonathan Joestar with a Stand
Many fans believe that Jonathan Joestar, despite not being a part of the stands system until later in the series, does have a stand. This belief is primarily based on a few key points and fan theories that provide alternative interpretations of the storyline.
Retconned Stand Theory
One of the most convincing arguments for Jonathan's stand comes from the 2000 art book, JoJo A-Go!Go!. According to this book, a scene from the beginning of Part 3, where Dio uses a Hermit Purple-like transparent stand, has been officially retconned. The book suggests that this stand is actually the stand of DIO's body, identified as Jonathan Joestar's. This explanation hinges on the concept that one can have only one stand, and since Dio's body is a separate entity from his head, it can hold its own stand.
Reincarnation Theory
Another popular and more romanticized fan theory posits that Jonathan has reincarnated as a stand standing next to his great-great-grandson Jotaro Kujo. Fans often find it appealing to see in the muscular build of Jotaro a symbol of the strong, heavy-locomotive body of their beloved protagonist. This theory is purely fan-made and not canon, but it adds a layer of emotional depth to the story, making it more captivating for those who grew up with Jonathan Joestar.
Theological and Historical Context
The concept of stands in the series is introduced in Season 2, when Jotaro Kujo and Muhammad Abdul engage in battle, and Ripple power is first seen. In the initial seasons, Jonathan relies on his Ripple power, which is a unique ability that allows him to manipulate and enhance his physical attributes. However, this does not negate the existence of a stand, which is a distinct and powerful entity in the JoJo universe.
The Introduction of Stands
The stands, as defined in the series, are powerful manifestations of a person's inner strength and emotions. They can take on various forms, abilities, and personality traits. The stands are closely tied to the concept of ancestral power, as seen in parts of the JoJo series involving the Joestar family legacy. Although Jonathan is not part of the stands system until later, his presence in the story and his actions suggest a deeper connection with the stands concept.
Conclusion
The question of whether Jonathan Joestar has a stand remains a matter of personal belief and fan interpretation. While some fans hold to the strong retconned theory, others support the reincarnation theory. Regardless of which perspective one adopts, the debate adds to the rich tapestry of the JoJo universe, making it a beloved and enduring series for many.