The Impact of the Arkenstone's Destruction on Thorin Oakenshield’s Motivation

Imagine a scenario where the Arkenstone, a pivotal and symbolic gem in J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Hobbit, was destroyed before Thorin Oakenshield claimed it. This alteration would have profound effects on Thorin’s motivation, negotiations, Bilbo Baggins’ role, and the overall storyline of the narrative.

Thorin's Motivation

The Arkenstone is a symbol of Thorin’s claim to the throne of Erebor and his heritage. It represents a deep-rooted sense of pride and identity. If the Arkenstone were destroyed before Thorin could possess it, his motivation to reclaim the mountain might not be as intense. This could alter his leadership approach and the decisions he makes regarding the treasure.

Conflict with the Elves and Men

The Arkenstone serves as a key bargaining chip in the negotiations between the dwarves, elves, and men. Its absence would eliminate a significant point of contention, possibly leading to a more straightforward and less hostile negotiation for the treasure distribution. This could result in fewer conflicts over the mountain’s wealth and a more amicable resolution.

Bilbo Baggins' Role

Bilbo Baggins’ decision to give the Arkenstone to Bard and the Elvenking was pivotal in his growth and the development of his moral compass. Without the Arkenstone, Bilbo might have fewer opportunities to demonstrate his cleverness and bravery. His role in mediating between the factions would be diminished, leading to a different dynamic in the storyline.

Thorin’s Descent into Paranoia

The Arkenstone’s existence exacerbates Thorin’s greed and paranoia, leading him to distrust his allies, including Bilbo. If the Arkenstone were destroyed, Thorin might not become as obsessed with the treasure. This change could prevent his tragic downfall and the ensuing conflict with his allies, altering the tragic arc of the story.

The Battle of the Five Armies

The buildup to the Battle of the Five Armies might be significantly different without the Arkenstone's influence. The motivations of the various factions could shift, potentially changing the alliances formed and the reasons for conflict among dwarves, elves, men, and orcs. This could affect the outcome of the battle in unforeseen ways.

Character Development

Thorin’s development throughout the story is closely tied to the Arkenstone. Its destruction would alter his character arc, potentially allowing him to maintain more of his nobility and honor instead of succumbing to greed and paranoia. This could lead to a more positive and genuine character development, providing readers with a different perspective on his transformation.

In summary, the destruction of the Arkenstone before Thorin obtained it would have significant implications for the storyline, its themes of greed, leadership, and friendship, and the outcomes for the characters involved. This hypothetical scenario could provide a fresh and intriguing take on the beloved tale of The Hobbit.