Harry Potter Characters: Changing Notions and Why

Introduction:

Harry Potter, the book series by J.K. Rowling, has captured the hearts of millions for decades. I've been a faithful reader of the series for years, revisiting the books numerous times, but lately, my perception of some characters has shifted. This article delves into how thoughts about certain characters in the Harry Potter series have evolved over time and why. We'll examine characters like Sirius Black, Albus Dumbledore, and Luna Lovegood, discussing their evolution and the reasons behind my changing opinions.

Sirius Black: Loyal but Manipulative

One of the characters whose portrayal has become more nuanced in my opinion is Sirius Black. Initially, he is portrayed as a valiant and loyal friend to Harry, which is still true. His moments of humor and genuine kindness resonate deeply. However, as the books progress, I've come to see him as a bit more manipulative than I initially thought. His behavior, such as saying, 'You’re less like your father than I thought,' is indeed frustrating to read.

This line is jarring because Harry, at only fifteen, already carries a heavy burden of being compared to his father. It's not a step to take lightly, especially when Sirius could have been more tactful. Moreover, in that specific instance, Sirius is more worried about his own safety than Harry's. While their bond is strong, that single line is a clear reflection of how I now view him.

Albus Dumbledore: A Complex Figure

Albus Dumbledore, one of the most iconic characters in the series, has had a fascinating journey for me. While I still appreciate his wisdom, power, and kindness, my initial admiration for him has evolved. At times, his cryptic nature and lack of straightforward guidance towards Harry are concerning. He knew both he and Harry would die someday, yet he didn't prepare Harry as much as he could have. This realization brings a sense of sadness for Dumbledore not being seen as a hero in his death.

Dumbledore's decision to go against Harry's wishes and take on greater risks for the greater good is complex. Had he informed Harry sooner, Harry could have taken on less grave responsibilities. The death of Dumbledore at the Battle of Hogwarts could have been prevented, and other significant victories achieved sooner. My view of him is still positive, but it is saturated with a sense of what could have been.

Luna Lovegood: Complex and Resilient

Luna Lovegood is another character who has grown on me significantly over time. Initially, I viewed her as a little quirky but mostly entertaining. Now, I see her in a more profound light. Her kindness, bravery, and resilience are endearing. She faced numerous challenges throughout her life, including the loss of her mother, dealing with an embarrassing father, and enduring bullying. Despite these hardships, Luna remained tenacious and bold.

Hermione and Harry's friendship with Luna feels like a beacon of hope and true friendship. Her interactions with Ron and Hermione, though sometimes exasperating, are filled with warmth and genuine care. Her ability to remain calm and maintain her perspective in trying situations is commendable. Luna is now one of my favorite characters in the series for her complexity and depth.

Minerva McGonagall: A Sassy and Complex Teacher

Minerva McGonagall, while always well-loved, has become an even more endearing character to me over the years. Initially, she was seen as a strict and powerful teacher with a hidden softer side. Now, her sass and genuine care for her students are more apparent. Lines such as 'have a biscuit,' 'just because she failed charms doesn’t mean that the subject is necessary useless,' and 'are you sure that you don’t need a tissue' are now appreciated as signs of her love for her students and her own cleverness.

Her defense of Dumbledore, her hatred for Umbridge, and her efforts to help Neville are highlights that continue to capture my heart. Her secret love for troublemakers and her willingness to stand up for her students, even in the face of authority, demonstrate the depth of her character. She is a complex and beloved figure.

Conclusion

Reading Harry Potter has enriched my life in many ways, and the characters have played a significant role in this journey. Sirius Black, Albus Dumbledore, Luna Lovegood, and Minerva McGonagall have all undergone changes in my perception, reflecting the intricate and evolving nature of these beloved characters. These shifts in opinion are a testament to the depth and complexity of J.K. Rowling’s storytelling.