Disney and the Representation of LGBTQ Characters: A Cost-Benefit Analysis

When will Disney finally include a gay prince in one of its films? The question has been a subject of debate in the LGBTQ community and among Disney fans for a long time. However, we have already seen instances of LGBTQ representation in Disney films, such as the character of Cinderella’s love interest in the Broadway musical 'Once Upon a One More Time'. Similarly, there was the remarkable film 'Under the Cherry Moon', which featured a gay prince as a main character. This article delves into the complexities and considerations involved in adding a gay prince to the Disney universe.

Historical Perspectives on LGBTQ Representation in Disney

The inclusion of LGBTQ characters in mainstream media, particularly in the realm of animation and children's entertainment, has been a gradual process. While there are still significant strides to be made, there has been a notable shift in recent years, with Disney introducing more diverse representation. Rumor has it that diaper-clad Elsa was going to come out in 'Frozen II', but this plot development was ultimately deemed too controversial. Nevertheless, the potential for further inclusivity remains.

The Logical Challenges of Portraying a Gay Prince

Portraying a gay prince presents a unique set of logistical challenges. As mentioned, a gay prince would need to ensure the continuity of his lineage. He would either need to adopt an heir or name a relative as his successor. Alternatively, he might strive to have heirs through marriage, but this would entail navigating cultural and political sensitivities. Regardless, children who inherit the throne are often not the best candidates, as evidenced by historical examples such as Edward VI of England or the fictional characters in 'Game of Thrones'.

Market and Audience Considerations

Disney's strategy in portraying or not portraying a gay prince is heavily influenced by market considerations. Given that gay men and lesbians would be unlikely audiences for a Disney kids' movie, this narrows the target demographic significantly. Parents who would take their children to see such a film are also a small group. The movie would need to appeal to a broader audience to succeed.

Why Disney May (or May Not) Include a Gay Prince

While skepticism reigns, there is a possibility that Disney is planning to introduce more LGBTQ characters in their films. The company might look to historical and ancient literature for inspiration, as there are countless stories that could fit this narrative. However, the decision to include or exclude a gay prince would ultimately depend on the potential financial rewards.

Disney's Cost-Benefit Analysis

Disney's inclusion of LGBTQ characters is not driven by altruism but by a cost-benefit analysis. The company aims to appeal to a diverse audience, including LGBTQ individuals, to increase sales and box office revenue. However, this strategy can be seen as a form of pandering, as it may not align with the company's true values. If the decision to include a gay prince proves to be a commercial failure, the backlash from both the LGBTQ community and (potentially) from those who believe the company is merely capitalizing on the movement could be severe.

Conclusion

While Disney's potential inclusion of a gay prince in its films remains uncertain, it is clear that the company's decision-making process is guided by market and financial considerations. As the LGBTQ community continues to advocate for greater representation in media, the pressure on companies like Disney to reflect this diversity increases. Whether or not Disney decides to include a gay prince, the conversation around LGBTQ representation in film remains ongoing and important.