Could Shoto Todoroki Beat All for One? An Analysis

The age-old question of whether Shoto Todoroki, one of the main characters from the popular anime series My Hero Academia, could challenge the antagonist All for One, has long been a topic of debate among fans. Here, we delve into a comprehensive analysis to determine if Todoroki stands a chance against All for One and why.

Strength

In terms of physical strength, it is reasonable to give the advantage to All for One. While Shoto Todoroki is a formidable opponent, he has yet to face a being of All for One's caliber. All for One has clashed with All Might, who is physically the second-strongest person in the series. Therefore, it would be prudent to give All for One the edge in this category.

Speed

The question of speed is more contested, but ultimately, I would give the advantage to Shoto Todoroki. His Phosphorus Technique makes him incredibly fast, allowing him to blitz even Dabi, who has considerable speed on his own. With this technique, Todoroki manages to strike Dabi before Dabi can even see his attack. This speed differential makes it difficult for opponents to react and counter him.

Durability

When it comes to durability, All for One holds the upper hand. In his base form, Shoto Todoroki was able to withstand an incinerating punch at 3000 degrees Celsius from Dabi, being thrown into a building. While impressive, this feat does not compare to All for One's capabilities. All for One survived an attack that would have destroyed any other hero, demonstrating his superior durability.

Intelligence (IQ)

Intelligence (IQ) is where All for One truly excels. His years of experience in battle and his advanced techniques make him a master strategist and tactician. Shoto Todoroki, while extremely skilled, has less experience and thus falls behind in this category.

Battle IQ

All for One’s extensive experience in battles and his well-honed strategy and tactics give him a significant edge in Battle IQ. Shoto Todoroki, while brilliant, has not had the same level of experience, making All for One the clear winner in this category.

Offense

Shoto Todoroki's fire-based abilities are highly offensive, making it difficult for opponents to come close to him in battle. His fire technique is so powerful that it can only be approached with caution, if at all.

Defense

Despite Shoto Todoroki's offensive prowess, All for One is more skilled at defending against attacks due to his extensive experience. All for One has a level of adaptability and defensive strategy that makes him harder to defeat.

Conclusion

Given these factors, the fight between Shoto Todoroki and All for One would be highly difficult for Todoroki. All for One's experience, durability, and offensive and defensive capabilities would likely give him the upper hand, making the matchup a high-difficulty challenge for Todoroki.

Note: He wasn't. He had to make huge ice mountains to make up for the air attacks from Deku's fingers alone. He was almost pushed off the arena because of Deku's fist. This indicates that Yes, Shoto Todoroki did take a much weaker punch from the One For All, and he didn't resist it because there was nothing for him to resist. Deduk's punch was significantly weaker compared to All for One's, especially after All for One's physical training and experience.

While Todoroki has made significant progress, All for One remains a formidable and strategic opponent, making the idea of him being beaten by Shoto Todoroki a high-difficulty scenario.