Convincing Eren to Kill Reiner: A Complex Ethical Dilemma in Attack on Titan

Introduction

Convincing Eren Yeager to kill Reiner Braun in the popular anime series 'Attack on Titan' is a complex task that requires a deep understanding of Eren's character and the overarching narrative. This article delves into the various emotional, ethical, and strategic arguments that could potentially sway Eren. It underscores the challenges and the necessity of such a decision to prevent further suffering and to maintain the ethical principles driving the Scout Regiment.

The Dilemma: Shared Goals

A strong argument for convincing Eren to kill Reiner involves emphasizing the shared goals of both Eren and Reiner. Despite their opposing sides, they have both been fighting for their respective people, whether it's Eren's desire to protect his people from the Titans or Reiner's initial intention to protect Marley from Eldian aggression. Highlighting that eliminating Reiner could prevent further conflict and suffering might resonate with Eren, who is constantly grappling with the notion of balancing justice and mercy.

The Dilemma: Strategic Advantage

Killing Reiner would weaken Marley's forces and give the Scouts a strategic advantage in the ongoing conflict. This can be framed as a necessary step to protect Eren's friends and allies. Emphasizing the broader implications of this strategic move can help Eren understand the immediate and long-term benefits, even if it means doing something difficult.

The Dilemma: Preventing Destruction

Reminding Eren of the catastrophic consequences that come with Titan transformations, such as mass destruction and loss of innocent lives, can create a moral imperative for him to act. Eren's moral and ethical convictions are deeply rooted in his desire to save lives and prevent suffering. By eliminating the threat, he could save countless lives and perhaps bring a step closer to ending the conflict.

The Dilemma: Personal Betrayal

Tapping into Eren's feelings of betrayal by Reiner, who was revealed to be the Armored Titan, can create a powerful emotional argument. This betrayal can be framed as a personal vendetta that Eren could fulfill, reinforcing his resolve. Eren's initial trust in Reiner and the subsequent discovery of his treachery might make this a compelling reason for him to act.

The Dilemma: Emphasizing Humanity

Encouraging Eren to maintain his humanity by not allowing Reiner to transform and cause more suffering can create a moral imperative for Eren to act. This argument appeals to Eren's core belief in humanity and the importance of preserving human life. It can create a sense of duty and responsibility that might ultimately sway his decision.

Conclusion

Ultimately, Eren's decision to kill Reiner would depend on his state of mind and his emotions at that moment. However, by emphasizing shared goals, strategic advantage, the prevention of destruction, personal betrayal, and the importance of maintaining humanity, one might have a better chance of persuading Eren to take this difficult but necessary step. The complex ethical dilemma at the heart of 'Attack on Titan' highlights the importance of justifying one's actions in a world filled with moral ambiguity and personal sacrifice.