Brokenstar and Tigerstar: A Comparison of Evilness in ‘The Warrior Cats’ Series

In the Warrior Cats series, two of the most controversial and feared characters are Brokenstar and Tigerstar. While both present evasive and harmful traits, this article delves into the comparison to determine who is truly the more evil of the two.

The Malicious Hand of Tigerstar

Tigerstar, often considered the epitome of evil among the Warrior Cats series, is indeed a character who takes actions that one might find unsettling. He is portrayed as a leader who tries to eliminate anyone who stands in his path, including planning to kill Firestar and suppressing those who oppose him. However, while his initial actions can be seen as ruthless, his leadership shifts as he grows older, and he eventually comes to be regarded as a competent ruler.

However, it is important to note that his initial actions, such as:

Plotting to kill Firestar Violating codexes by engaging in combat with a leader and allies' mentor Taking drastic measures to consolidate power

these acts, while severe, do not quite match the outright brutality and disregard for life that Brokenstar exhibits.

The Unyielding Essence of Brokenstar

On the other hand, Brokenstar is undoubtedly one of the most unyielding villains in the series. His actions span a range of heinous acts that leaving a lasting impact on the beloved characters and the storyline of Warrior Cats.

Brokenstar's actions include:

Engaging in a series of battles against WindClan apprentices Refusing to aid injured comrades and disregarding their medical needs Concocting a plot that led to the death of Foxheart Harshly training his apprentices and forcing them to fight with unsheathed claws Killing his own father, Raggedstar Removing and exiling the elders from the camp, rendering them helpless Making a kit only three moons old an apprentice, resulting in the death of another kit, Mosspaw Praising the apprentices for the death of their littermate Crucial in the death of a pregnant queen, Poppyfrost, during his first permanent death

Each of these acts not only demonstrates Brokenstar's uncaring nature but also his willingness to go to any lengths, even at the cost of life and harmony within the clans.

Conclusion: Who Is More Evil?

While both Brokenstar and Tigerstar exhibit significant instances of malice, Brokenstar appears to be the most incorrigibly malevolent character. Tigerstar may have initiated many harmful and aggressive actions, but he also shows a level of respect and tactical leadership that Brokenstar lacks.

Brokenstar stands out for his relentless and total disregard for the lives and well-being of others. His actions, ranging from direct violence and deceit to the manipulation of young and innocent warriors, paint him as the more diabolical of the two characters.

Ultimately, when comparing these two individuals, Brokenstar's sheer disregard for life, his willingness to harm not just his enemies but also his allies and innocent characters, clearly places him as the more villainous of the two in the Warrior Cats series.