Understanding the Battle of Five Armies: A Literary Analysis of Bilbo and Thorin

Often a topic of debate among The Hobbit enthusiasts, the question of whether Bilbo Baggins or Thorin Oakenshield is more powerful can be complex. While the former walked away from the disastrous Battle of Five Armies, the latter met his end inside a tomb. This essay delves into the depth of their characters and highlights the unique traits that made them #8220;mighty,#8221; evaluating the concepts of power, courage, and legacy as we explore the ...

Bilbo Baggins: The Unlikely Hero

Bilbo Baggins, the toy hobbit of Middle-earth, embodies the idea of a hero who is more than just a warrior. He possesses a natural talent for magic and wits, which he uses to cleverly navigate the dangers he faces. His journey from a simple hobbit enjoying a peaceful life to an invaluable member of the company of Thorin Oakenshield displays remarkable growth. Bilbo's most significant moments of power include his ability to handle the ring and his use of the ring to sneak into Gollum's lair, ultimately leading to the acquisition of the precious elven gem.

Thorin Oakenshield: Builder of a Nation

Contrary to Bilbo's unassuming beginning, Thorin Oakenshield's story is one of inherited nobility and duty. A descendant of Durin the Deathless, Thorin wears the title of King Under the Mountain. His primary role throughout the narrative is to reclaim the lost wealth and honor of his people. Thorin exhibits a strong sense of duty and leadership, which he uses to build an alliance amongst various races. His valiant efforts in the Battle of Five Armies, although seemingly futile, highlight the risk he was willing to take to secure the future of his kingdom.

Power in the Context of "The Hobbit"

The concept of power in "The Hobbit" is multifaceted and defined by different context and situations. For Bilbo, power lies in his ability to outsmart boars and spiders, to handle a powerful magic ring, and to find the courage to confront Gollum for his survival and the success of his mission. On the contrary, Thorin's power is rooted in strategic planning, leadership, and the authority he wields as the descendant of an old and noble line of dwarves. The Battle of Five Armies, which does not end in the traditional sense of victory, highlights the different forms of power each character possesses and how they evolved during the course of the narrative.

The Journey of Self-Discovery

Both Bilbo and Thorin undergo significant character development via their respective journeys. Bilbo's transformation, from the reluctant young hobbit to a brave, resourceful hero, showcases his exceptional ability to adapt swiftly to new and often dire circumstances. His viewpoint is deeply emotional, as he experiences the fear of war and the joy of discovery, which aligns him with the common experience of his readers and the broader audience. Thorin's journey, too, is one of disenchantment and eventual enlightenment. Initially driven by the desire for wealth and power, Thorin's loss in battle and his realization of the importance of unity among different races speak to the value of the human spirit and the potential for change.

Legacy and Aftermath of the Battle

Bilbo's exit from the narrative after the Battle of Five Armies, nearly despite the outcome, underscores the personal triumph he achieves. In the end, he returns to Hobbiton, seemingly unscathed by the harrowing experience, and goes on to live the rest of his days as a renowned and honored hero. In contrast, Thorin's fate is far less fortunate. His final struggle with Azog and his eventual death signify the ultimate sacrifice made in the pursuit of a greater good. Thorin's legacy, however, is not one of futility but of a leader who dared to strive for the betterment of his nation, and who sacrificed everything in the process.

Reflections on Power, Courage, and Legacy

Bilbo and Thorin's characters serve as a reflection on the nature of power and its various manifestations. Bilbo's strength lies in his wits and ability to navigate unforeseen challenges, while Thorin's resides in his leadership and vision. The central questions posed in The Hobbit reflect on the broader themes of courage, self-sacrifice, and the broader idea of heroism. Ultimately, both characters remind us of the profound depths of human potential and the various forms that power can take.