Is Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood the Best Anime of All Time?

When discussing the best anime of all time, opinions vary widely. According to MyAnimeList (MAL), Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (FMA: Brotherhood) has long held the spot for the top-rated anime series. However, with titles like Attack on Titan (AOT) close behind, it's worth examining their relative merits to determine whether one truly emerges as the esteemed champion of all anime contemporaries.

The Top-Rated Anime: Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood

Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood stands tall in the realm of highly acclaimed anime series. The show has consistently maintained a remarkable score, indicating its widespread appeal and critical acclaim. It tells the tale of Edward and Alphonse Elric, who pursue a way to restore their lost body parts through alchemy. The narrative explores themes of love, loss, and the complexity of morality, leading many to argue in favor of FMA: Brotherhood's place as the best anime of all time.

Attack on Titan: A Viable Contender

However, it's impossible to overlook the potential of Attack on Titan as a contender for the crown of the best anime of all time. AOT, with its gripping storyline, atmospheric depiction of a world teetering on the brink of despair, and expert character development, challenges the belief that FMA: Brotherhood holds a monopoly on this title. Critics often praise AOT's ability to hook viewers with intense action sequences and intricate plot twists, making it a highly engaging and impactful viewing experience.

Factors for Evaluating Anime Success

Evaluating which anime is the best involves considering numerous factors:

Storytelling and Plot Complexity: A compelling narrative that keeps viewers hooked and leaves them questioning the story even after rewatching. Character Development: The evolution of characters that resonates with viewers and makes them care deeply about the outcomes of their journeys. The exploration of meaningful and thought-provoking themes that provide depth and significance to the story. The quality of animation and visual storytelling that enhances the overall viewing experience. The ability to rewatch and find new layers of meaning and enjoyment in subsequent viewings.

My Personal Take on the Contenders

From a personal perspective, both Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood and Attack on Titan have their unique strengths. FMA: Brotherhood excels in its thematic exploration and character development, while AOT stands out for its action and suspense. However, when it comes to rewatchability and the ability to revel in the grand revelations over and over, AOT is a standout. This episodic viewing experience makes AOT a must-watch for anime enthusiasts.

Conclusion: The Quest for the Best Anime of All Time

The debate over the best anime of all time is subjective and profound. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood's consistent high ratings and critical acclaim place it at the top of many lists, but Attack on Titan's intense storytelling and thematic depth present a compelling rival. Ultimately, the choice of the best anime is a journey of personal preference and experience. Whether one Side with FMA: Brotherhood or embraces the narrative and visual richness of AOT, there's no denying the impact of both in the world of anime.