Ariel's Deserved Exclusion as a Disney Princess: A Critical Analysis

The Disney Princess canon has long been a subject of debate among fans and critics. While many argue about who should and should not be considered an official Disney Princess, Ariel stands as a prime example of a character not fit for the title. This article will explore Ariel's character traits and actions that make her an underwhelming role model, and will question whether such a character deserves her place within the iconic Disney Princess lineup.

Why Ariel Is Not a Fit for the Disney Princess Criterion

Ariel, the protagonist of The Little Mermaid, is often described as one of the most iconic Disney Princesses. However, upon deeper consideration, it becomes evident that her character is riddled with flaws that make her an unsuitable role model for young girls.

Disobedience and Selfishness

Ariel's willingness to defy her father's orders and rush into a potentially dangerous situation with Eric serves as a problematic example for young viewers. Her naivety and disregard for the potential consequences of her actions set a worrying precedent. By ignoring her father's warnings and running away to find a love-struck husband, she embodies a classic archetype of female rebellion, but at a cost that might seem irresponsible and unintelligent to many.

Desperate Actions and Ethical Choices

One of the most troubling aspects of Ariel's character is her willingness to make a deal with Ursula, the sea witch. She agrees to give Ursula her voice in exchange for three days as a human, even though it comes with grave risks. This decision not only betrays a lack of trust in herself and her ability to navigate the human world but also promotes the idea that black magic and unethical means are acceptable. This is a significant departure from the values of loyalty and integrity typically promoted in Disney's more reputable Princesses.

Lack of Selflessness and Responsibility

Another key aspect that contradicts the concept of a Disney Princess is Ariel's selfish behavior. Throughout the story, she prioritizes her personal happiness over the well-being of her father and kingdom. When she leaves her underwater home, friends, and family to be with Eric, she showcases a severely flawed sense of self-preservation and disregard for others. This behavior is at odds with the selfless and often sacrificial acts traditionally associated with Disney Princesses like Cinderella or Snow White, who always put the needs of others before their own.

The Critique of Ariel's Father-Daughter Relationship

Ariel's relationship with her father, King Triton, is another focal point of criticism. Their interactions are marked by authority and control on Triton's part and rebellious obedience on Ariel's. Triton's authoritarianism is highlighted even further when he transforms into a polyp when he takes Ariel's place in Ursula's deal. While this transformation is a consequence of his actions, it nonetheless emphasizes his tyrannical behavior and Ariel's submission to it. A more constructive and understanding father-daughter dynamic might have provided a more balanced and healthy character development for Ariel.

Conclusion: Is Ariel a Good Role Model?

Given the analysis above, it can be argued that Ariel does not deserve to be an official Disney Princess. Her actions and character traits, while perhaps appealing to young viewers in a superficial sense, do not align with the core values and behaviors expected of a Disney Princess. Instead, she represents behaviors that could negatively impact young girls' development, such as disobedience, desperation, and a lack of selflessness.

While some might defend Ariel's character, it is crucial to consider the long-term cultural impact of promoting these traits. Disney Princesses are often imitated by young girls and serve as role models, and thus it is imperative that they exemplify the best qualities: courage, kindness, and selflessness. Repositioning Ariel to a supporting role in the Disney Princess series could help ensure that future generations of young girls learn from the wholesome and inspiring characters that Disney continues to produce.