Why Aragorn Believed Arwen Could Set Sail to Valinor

The concept of half-elven choice is not a simple, everyday phenomenon for Aragorn, a character who deeply understands the complexities of elven and human relations. Unlike his ancestors, no clear decisive moment marked Arwen's choice to sail to Valinor, the western paradise of the elven afterlife, as there was none for earlier legendary figures like Beren and Luthien. This ambiguity is a critical aspect of Arwen and Aragorn's story and its interpretation.

Imrahil's Influence and Aragorn's Familiarity

Aragorn was undoubtedly familiar with tales of earlier elven-human unions. One of the most notable is the story of Imrazor, the ancestor of Imrahil, who married Mithrellas, an elf maiden, and later sailed into the West. This story served as a poignant reminder and a precedent for Aragorn, offering him a glimpse into the future. If Mithrellas, an elf maiden, could both marry a mortal man and sail to the West, why couldn't Arwen do the same?

Arwen’s Choice and the War of the Ring

Years before the War of the Ring, even before its inception, Arwen made her choice. In Lothlorien, she saw Aragorn dressed as an elf lord, and at that moment, she realized the depth of her feelings for him. However, Aragorn was unaware of her true feelings and the immense weight of her decision. Her future was bound to the sea, yet she had to live her life as a mortal alongside him. The knowledge of her choice weighed heavily on her heart, and as Aragorn laid down his kingship and life during the Fourth Age of Middle-earth, it was her readiness to embrace that choice that he relied on.

Symbolism and Themes in the Story

The narrative of Aragorn and Arwen's relationship is rich with symbolism and themes. The choice of half-elves is a central theme, reflecting the cultural and personal struggles of those who bridge two worlds. Arwen's departure to Valinor symbolizes the end of an era, the transition from mortal to immortal life, and the enduring love that transcends worlds. The concept of mixed ethnicity and the choice between two lives are profound and resonate deeply with readers and viewers of The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit.

Conclusion

Understanding why Aragorn believed Arwen could set sail to Valinor requires delving into the complexities of the choice of half-elves and the specific circumstances of Arwen's story. The influence of previous examples, such as Imrazor and Mithrellas, prepared Aragorn for the possibility of Arwen's departure. The knowledge of her choice, made long before the War of the Ring, underscores the depth and significance of their bond, and the enduring love that defined their tale in the Fourth Age of Middle-earth.