Why I Feel Bad That Ahsoka Can Do Psychometry

As a passionate fan of the Star Wars universe, I often find myself engrossed in the intricate details of the story and the characters that populate it. One such character is Ahsoka Tano, whose growth as a Jedi has been nothing short of phenomenal. However, when it comes to her having the ability to perform psychometry, I can't help but feel a sense of discomfort. This rare ability, where a Jedi can perceive past events by touching objects, raises several questions and concerns, especially in the context of Ahsoka's character development and storytelling.

The Rarity and Value of Psychometry in the Star Wars Universe

Psychometry is indeed one of the rarest abilities in the Star Wars galaxy, and as such, it holds a unique place in the lore. Only a handful of known Jedi have been blessed (or cursed, in some cases) with this gift. Notable figures like Cal Kestis from the Jedi Order's Eclipse trilogy, Quinlan Vos from the Clone Wars series, and Karr Nuq Sin from the High Republic era, all possess this extraordinary talent.

The inclusion of psychometry in the Star Wars narrative contributes to the mythos and adds depth to the Jedi Order. It's a rare gift, so infrequently bestowed that it becomes a symbol of a Jedi’s unique connection to the Force and their past.

Ahsoka and the Critique of Psychometry

However, I must admit that I feel a strong sense of reluctance when Ahsoka is endowed with psychometry. This feeling is rooted in several factors. Firstly, Ahsoka's character represents a powerful and well-developed storytelling arc that fans have come to appreciate. Her journey from Padawan to traveling companion and finally to her own path as a formidable warrior and strategist is nothing short of inspiring. Adding an ability like psychometry feels unnecessary and somewhat contrived, given that she already has an impressive track record of real prowess and resourcefulness.

Moreover, the inclusion of psychometry often comes across as a plot convenience. In many respects, it serves the story more than the character. The idea that she can instantly access past events by touching objects feels less authentically challenging and more like a crutch for the plot. This stark contrast between her practical and combat skills and her psychometric abilities makes the story feel disjointed and less believable.

Wooden Dialogues and the Overall Quality of the Ahsoka TV Show

The quality of the writing in the Ahsoka TV show is another significant factor contributing to my negative response to her psychometric ability. The show has been criticized for its wooden and simplistic dialogue, which often fails to capture the depth and nuance of the characters and their interactions. This lackluster writing style makes the narrative feel flat and unengaging. Psychometry, in such a context, seems even more out of place and serves to further highlight the show's shortcomings in crafting a compelling and immersive experience.

Is Ahsoka Tano Dave Filoni’s Baby?

It's also worth noting that Ahsoka Tano is often described as Dave Filoni's baby, a sentiment that is prevalent among fans. Filoni, the creator of the clone troopers and the mind behind much of the Clone Wars and Rebels content, has a deep affinity for Ahsoka. This personal connection can be both a blessing and a curse. On the one hand, fans appreciate the care and attention that goes into Ahsoka's development. On the other hand, it raises questions about objectivity in storytelling and whether her character is being shaped not just by what makes for an engaging story, but also by the desires of the creator.

The convenient nature of psychometry, as an ability, aligns with this tendency. It provides a narrative tool that can enhance or excuse plot shortcomings while also reinforcing Ahsoka's status as a rare and precious character. However, for a character as dynamic and complex as Ahsoka, her abilities should be reflective of her strengths and her journey, not just plot devices.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the addition of psychometry to Ahsoka's abilities in the Star Wars universe enriches the broader lore, it often does not serve the character's individual growth and the storytelling on a deeper level. It is a testament to the rarity and value of psychometry that it garners attention and respect, but in Ahsoka's case, it seems more like a plot convenience rather than an integral part of her character.

The quality of writing in the Ahsoka TV show, its wooden dialogues, and the sometimes contrived nature of certain plot points further contribute to this feeling of discomfort. Ultimately, the storytelling should be more nuanced and less reliant on these types of plot devices to showcase a character's abilities and growth.