A Comprehensive Analysis of Star Trek: Which Series Had the Best Plots and Characters?

For many fans of Star Trek, the debate over which series had the best plots and characters never truly ends. While personal opinions and preferences differ, this article delves into a detailed analysis of the various Star Trek series to help determine which, in the eyes of many fans, truly stands out as the best.

The Best Story Arcs: Deep Space Nine

Deep Space Nine (DS9) has often been praised for its intricate story arcs, which are both long and ongoing. Unlike other series that may feel overwhelming with too many storylines, DS9 manages to balance its main plotlines with side-quests, making the experience a rich, engaging one for viewers. Other series, such as Star Trek: Prodigy, are also considered strong contenders for second place in terms of story arcs.

Story Arcs in Major Series:

Deep Space Nine: Character development and ongoing storytelling Star Trek: Prodigy: Strong narrative with engaging side-quests Torpedo Shock Movies (TMPs): Genesis Trilogy, including The Wrath of Khan, The Search for Spock, The Voyage Home

Best Standalone Episodes: Star Trek: No Limits

Star Trek: No Limits (SNW) is often highlighted for its standout standalone episodes. In just its first season, SNW has managed to produce episodes that are considered superior to even iconic series like Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS), Trek Animated Series (TAS), and Star Trek: The Next Generation (TNG). Even the weakest episodes of SNW are regarded as above average, which is a testament to the quality of storytelling in this series.

Standalone Episodes in Major Series:

Star Trek: No Limits (SNW): Superb standalone episodes TOS TAS: Variable quality TNG: Generally good, with some weaker episodes

Most Realistically Fleshed-Out Characters: Deep Space Nine

When it comes to deep, 3-dimensional characters, Deep Space Nine is often cited as the standout. The show features a massive ensemble cast, where no character feels ignored. The character of Prophet Sisko is particularly noted for his multi-dimensional background, making him one of the most compelling characters in Star Trek history. Other series also have strong character development, but DS9 stands out in this category.

Characters in Major Series:

Deep Space Nine: Impressive ensemble cast with well-developed characters Torpedo Shock Movies (TMPs): Classic crew at their finest Star Trek: No Limits (SNW): Enjoyable, realistic characters Star Trek: Prodigy: Engaging and multi-dimensional characters

Most Enjoyable Characters: Next Generation/Prodigy

For many fans, the characters in Star Trek: The Next Generation (TNG) and Star Trek: Prodigy are the most entertaining. TNG brings back the iconic characters of the classic series, while Prodigy offers a fresh look at the Star Trek universe with a new cast of young characters who breathe life into the franchise. Both series have allowed characters to grow and evolve significantly, making them enjoyable to watch.

Enjoyable Characters in Major Series:

Star Trek: Prodigy: Enjoyable, realistic, and engaging characters Star Trek: The Next Generation (TNG): Iconic, enjoyable, and growing characters

In conclusion, while opinions on the best Star Trek series may vary, several series stand out in specific categories. Deep Space Nine shines in story arcs and character development, Star Trek: No Limits offers the best standalone episodes, and Star Trek: The Next Generation and Star Trek: Prodigy both present enjoyable, evolving characters. Each series has its unique strengths, contributing to the enduring legacy of Star Trek.